Feedback on Map's Tiles Needed

[Player]

Hi guys I have a dilemma. I do maps in WC1 Style but as I can't copy the style 100% I need help from the HiveWorkshop community on this.

So please look at the pictures and write your opinion - Pictures 1&2 are from Original Warcraft I; Pictures 3&4 are with WC3 Tileset; Pictures 5&6 are with WC1 Custom Tileset. What do you say, which one would be better to use in order to get the WC1 feel the closest?

p.s. Please take only the Tileset into consideration...

 

[Chaosium]

Pictures 5 & 6 are actually closer to the original imo, but we can barely see a difference between the two shades of green in screen 6, which is kind of weird.

I can say that if I were to play such a map with tiles 3 & 4 , I would not say "omg author didn't respect tile colors wtf haxx !&!§§" =P

 

[Player]

In picture 6 there are actually 3 different shades of green...
Yeah I know, it was also very hard for me to make it as I barely could see the different shades in the original game...

To Chaosium - so in other words you say it doesn't really matter?!

Ok I've decided to dry and do something in order to fix the road!

 

[Chaosium]

Yep, at least for me, tile colors don't really matter (unless you use really out of place stuff)

I'd rather focus on gameplay mechanics, immersion and lore in first place.