Moderator
M
Moderator
08:34, 30th Mar 2014
Hell_Master: Map approved with a rating of 4/5 (Recommended). See moderator's review and mini-mod's (eubz's) review regarding the map:
Hell_Master: Map approved with a rating of 4/5 (Recommended). See moderator's review and mini-mod's (eubz's) review regarding the map:
Hell_Master;2505401 said:Review emerges!
I had a look through your map because of the broken screenshots in the description but that does not matter for it's the terrain what matters but if you want, you could fix the descriptions.
The terrain is simply amazing as a start. Terrain has great details in it: wisely placed doodads and great destuctible usage, terrain's not flat and has good ground variation: those hills simply makes the terrain much better, terrain has good tile variations but those manmade tiles mixed with natural tiles looks a bit unfitting to the terrain, I would suggest sticking to natural tiles which you have started with the template and etc.
I would like to keep this simple and short but overall, this fits the standards and is a great terrain Template recommended for all. Rated 4/5 and Approved.
eubz;2505390 said:
The Hive Workshop Official
Map Reviewer: eubz
Map Name: Elven Forests
Map Author: Forsaken
Map Uploader: Forsaken
Originality
Though this map uses the UTM, it has its own original ambiance. You have made this template a feel of a forest. It also feels like a home for elves.
Score: 75/100
★ Special Recommendation ★
Presentation
Nice presentation. You have images to show a glance to what the map looks like. Though UTM has its own way of presenting the people who worked with the models therein, it is also better to tell us that you have used UTM in this project.
Score: 60/100
Terrain
The terrain has been beautifully decorated with correct doodads. Wise use of tile variations and because this is UTM, what more can I say about the doodad models but superb. It is on the mappers skill of using them that made this map the best. You are a good terrainer at this point.
Score: 80/100
★ Special Recommendation ★
You can add few neutral units to make this map alive.
You might want also to delete the custom loading screen because this is a template but that's just a very small issue.
Final Score: 71.667/100
4/5 Vote for Approval
Contact: (Visitor Message) / (Private Message) / (Map Reviewers)