Defence map; old school or modern?

[Coolty44]

Ok, so latley I've had 2 copies of the exact same map (terrain and basic trigger wise). One is a more modern warfare map with 3 triggered spells, and the other is an old school warcraft map, that has a few of my spells in it, and is farther from completion. I'm wondering though, what would be easier to pull off? I know that the warcraft version would be more flexable for ideas, and wouldnt have to to stick to relalistic weaponery, but the modern one is something that you dont see every day in warcraft.

The background on it is a zombie map, with wave after wave of an ever-growing, stronger zombies, abominations, spitters, etc etc. The modern one has a nice system based off mana shield that would be a great way to trigger a AI. But the warcraft one has more importated meterial, more flexablility, and is generally easier to pull off, as theres many resources I can use to make it.

So which one sounds more interesting? Old school or modern?

 

[Hijax]

it really depends on how you does it. if you do lots of cool effects and custom doodads to make it appear realistic, i'd take the modern one, else the warcraft one.

so its as you said, the WC one is easier to pull.

 

[Solecompanysole]

I think modern would be my choice....

 

[Witch Doctor]

I think modern to... I am bored by the old school maps because I have play and play and play them again. I want to see something new !!!! :\
But I love the old school maps to .... what did you think if you combine the style of an old map with the stile of a moedern map ???

Combine the mana shield ideea with thosands of zombie , abominations and other monstosity. good ideea

 

[Rowboat]

Modern maps are funny, but WC3 are funniest

I pick Wc3 Style! Because we all know anything about the modern world, putting something unique fantasy WC3 stuff in it will be more interesting.

 

[The World Is Flat]

Wc3 style...
Or make the modern one Sci-fi.
we accually see too much of modern map these days.

 

[Trillium]

old school warcraft

i'm not fond of sci-fi

 

[Coolty44]

Thanks for the feed back guys. I'm going old-school now since I tried a trigger merge to get tons of new triggers into the modern map. Now its corrupted behond belief.