Custom Castle Defense

[Moderator]

08:31, 1st Jul 2010
ap0calypse: Rejected

 

[GONZALORD]

thanks to the original author for leting me edit their map

THE MAP IS NOT PROTECTED. YOU CAN EDIT IT ONLY WITH MY PERMISE

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fh8VfFH78jY
A garry's mod fun video lol

 

[dead-man-walking]

...It's not 'your' Map. Srsly. Remove that from Description for starters.

And unprotected means Free-to-Edit. Light Protection means Free-to-Learn.
And I doubt the highly skilled modders of Hive would ever "steal" this.

 

[BlackKnightTGS]

Decent enough. 3/5.

 

[GONZALORD]

play the map and comment later
please don't say that

 

[dead-man-walking]

I quoted the Map Submission Rules of Hive. The ones with Red means that you have broke it.

Original Work
Maps must be significantly worked on, or entirely created, by their submitter.
(You have yet to show us a proof that you are allowed to edit this)

Originality
Maps must be distinctively different from other maps in concept. This may include story, gameplay, goals, etc, but restricts maps which are effectively clones of older versions, such as most LOAP and Footman Wars maps.

Gameplay
Maps must be fairly fun and decently balanced.

Presentation
Maps must have adequate spelling and grammar. Maps must contain a valid author and map name. Maps must contain a proper description of what the map is about.
(I see no decent Description here)

Seriously. I'm just acting nice now. Those that broke the rules usually just got reported.

 

[Dakillakan]

play the map and comment later
please don't say that

Hehe... please don't say that you stole this map from the original user without his or her consent... I have played the original Custom Castle Defense from RoC and his/her remake in TFT. No offense buddy, but you stole this map. Although it is unprotected in your description you claim that you made it, asking for permission to edit this with your permission.

 

[Devious_Machine]

This may be a clone, but if he got the permission to edit it, i guess it is ok. Until proof is show (something more than your word) i give it a vote for rejection

 

[ap0calypse]

Hehe... please don't say that you stole this map from the original user without his or her consent... I have played the original Custom Castle Defense from RoC and his/her remake in TFT. No offense buddy, but you stole this map. Although it is unprotected in your description you claim that you made it, asking for permission to edit this with your permission.

Explain this, GONZALORD.
Did you or did you not steal the map (editing without permission and saying you made it is stealing)?

 

[GONZALORD]

i don't made the map only edited and perfectione it making it more fun and enjoyable.
it's that a problem?
i only make like 4 hours of triggers and put new models and levels

 

[ap0calypse]

It is a problem if you did not get permission from the original author, yes.
You also didn't "perfectione" it, as there are still a lot of leaks left (I'm guessing the original triggers didn't have leaks and all your triggers do, meaning you're the one who 'ruined' the map concerning triggers).
The terrain is (still) not really good, adding models is just an aesthetic thing and shouldn't be counted as 'editing a map', it takes no skill at all.


Are you Netforce2k4?

 

[GONZALORD]

ok thanks