Crystal Kingdom

[Moderator]

Vengeancekael: Private Message
Date: 2011/Nov/15 17:55:38

Reasons:

Other:
Check out the tutorials section: Tutorials
Check out the Map Development Section: Map Development Section
Check out the World Editor Help Zone (Trigger issues, object editor, overall WE issues): WE Help Zone
Comment: *Neat idea how you've balanced the BM
*Filled up terrain, looks very northrend-like, fitting doodads, a lot height and terrain tile variation
*Random item drops (also level based)
*No creeps close to the tavern
*Every shop is on the map
*Symmetric
*1 Fountain of Health at one side and a fountain of mana at the other side of the map
*Sufficient wood
*Bonus goldmines
*Nice way of putting down breakable ice blocks, I think you can still use those at other parts of the map, which would introduce a lot of strategies
*Green creeps close to starting points, yellow creeps guarding shops and red creeps guarding fountains

*Good
*Bad

Overall I think you've done a great job, this is a superb melee map.

(Also put the screenshot in the description under hidden tags:

[hidden=]SCREENSHOT[/hidden]

)
Admin Contact - Resource Moderation - Rules

 

[Vengeancekael]

*Neat idea how you've balanced the BM
*Filled up terrain, looks very northrend-like, fitting doodads, a lot height and terrain tile variation
*Random item drops (also level based)
*No creeps close to the tavern
*Every shop is on the map
*Symmetric
*1 Fountain of Health at one side and a fountain of mana at the other side of the map
*Sufficient wood
*Bonus goldmines
*Nice way of putting down breakable ice blocks, I think you can still use those at other parts of the map, which would introduce a lot of strategies
*Green creeps close to starting points, yellow creeps guarding shops and red creeps guarding fountains

*Good
*Bad

Overall I think you've done a great job, this is a superb melee map.

Rated 5/5 and approved.

 

[lonepair]

Thanks a lot. I've hidden the screenshot.

 

[Ken-E]

Full Review

Imma gonna try this out for sure, I'll leave comment soon.

EDIT: Like Vengeancekael said, this is a superb melee map! The terraining was also great, well emplaced doodads, clever creep position and enough gold mines for two players. Also, there is plenty of trees to start with, symmetrical bases. Everything was great, however, you forgot to put the short description to your map. So overall this is your only problem, fix that.

Score: 4.5/5 Good job!
And rep+ for your work.

 

[lonepair]

OK I realized that the description is not in English lol. I've updated it now, but there isn't enough space in the description so I have to omit the last sentence.

 

[eubz]

Woah! Highly Recommended... LOL!

 

[Dess_26]

A quality map. I enjoyed playing it, even though I was defeated
5/5 + Rep from me.

 

[Dylennis]

Saw a lot of pro games on this map, and I can see why. Very nice map, keep making them!!! Maybe if they're all this caliber we can stop seeing the same maps (EI, AI, LR, TS, TM, etc.) over and over again. 5/5.