Cold Bath

[Moderator]

22:45, 18th Aug 2013
Orcnet: needs more work

 

[Theoden of KoMe]

good map but why there are gold mines in the sea?

 

[Daffa]

^Naval Mines
Warcraft 2 Decency

@OP
But why you remove the humans =/

 

[DrarenThiralas]

^Naval Mines
Warcraft 2 Decency

@OP
But why you remove the humans =/

I haven't made them yet.

 

[Theoden of KoMe]

you should first make them and then update them map again
Thats priority one if you want to improve your map

 

[DrarenThiralas]

you should first make them and then update them map again
Thats priority one if you want to improve your map

My plans for this map are now this:
1.Add 3 more orc heroes.
2.Add Humans.
So the humans are coming shortly!

 

[UndeadImmortal]

Looks awesome!

 

[Legal_Ease]

+ rep This looks cool! Nice description, fun concept, good looking race! Can't wait to see the humans...

 

[DrarenThiralas]

I already began my work on the humans. As for the island - i will definitely make one. There is little to no use to that part of the map anyway.

 

[Twilight]

Comment

A nice alterd melee map, it seems to be god description is nice
_______________
Rating:
5/5

Terrain

Terrain is empty, add more islands in the water, it could be nice
___________________
Rating:
3/5

Gameplay

A basic alterd melee map, I like the custom models you use.
____________________
Rating:
4/5

Final Rating:

Terrain:3/5
Gameplay:4/5
Comment:5/5

FINAL RATING:
4/5

Suggestions
-Terrain can be Improved
-Gameplay can be Improved

 

[DrarenThiralas]

Twilight, thank you for you feedback. I will gladly work on improving terrain for the next version. Also, will you please post more specific suggestions on improving gameplay?

 

[Xonok]

This map might get interesting to me.

 

[Twilight]

Will you please post more specific suggestions on improving gameplay?

Well I was thinking about add an custom race that is only for a cpu. Make an Island at the center, add the cpu player on the island make AI, and there you have it, but You dont have to do this, it is a suggestion, but if you do I will change rating to 5/5

 

[DrarenThiralas]

I'm afraid that this is impossible, as naval combat is an important part of gameplay, and AI can't use nor ships nor naval transports. I guess it won't be fun if that ai just sits there and builds more and more buildings and units until he's out of gold, then just remains struck there doing nothing.

 

[Twilight]

Then Make workers that build ship yards, or building that trains zepplines.

 

[DrarenThiralas]

Version 1.8 with full human race is now in testing phase.

Then Make workers that build ship yards, or building that trains zepplines.

I tried. AI can have them, but can't use. There is no such function at the ai editor that can be used to make them use shipyards or zeppelins.

 

[Theoden of KoMe]

You can add it yourself to build them.

 

[DrarenThiralas]

But how?

 

[FUJI]

But how?

By using Trigger Editor. Not AI Editor..

 

[FUJI]

Btw,

jakeZinc's Ratings


Terrain 4.5/5 Needs Improvements.

ScreenShots 4/5 Needs more screenshots.

Starting Units 4/5 Why only 3 units?

Late Game Forces 4/5 Needs more forces or units.

Player Numbers 3/5 Im suggesting 4 players but it's up to you .

Doodads 3/5 Add more doodads in the sea.

AI Difficulty 3/5 Needs more statistics and difficults.

Custom Model Used 5/5 Great!.

Trees 4/5 Suggesting add more trees.

Number of Heroes 4/5 Suggesting add more heroes to Improves the Gameplay Experienced and Strategies.

Final Rating 4/5

Reputation Points 1 point

 

[DrarenThiralas]

"AI Difficulty 3/5 Needs more statistics and difficults." Err... there's really no AI in this map.
"Player Numbers 3/5 Im suggesting 4 players but it's up to you ." This is first map in a series, right now i'm releasing next one with 3 players. Next maps will feature more players.
EDIT: released, http://www.hiveworkshop.com/forums/maps-564/fortress-sorrows-239648/?prev=status=p

 

[Orcnet]

Gameplay needs some improvement, the idea of oil tankers is unique and reminds me of the wc3 game, still game play and battleground statistics is somewhat void right now:

-Player X from below has a tight cliff edge with a small crossing for shipyards, this gives the player a tower defense structure and the tight path enhances the defense value, this is not a good practice and very overwhelming idea.

-Terrain is too plain, do please read tutorials about proper terrain landscaping and such it will give the map quality

-As I have reviewed your other map, some of the units is too overpowered I suggest you nuke them down a bit especially the level Paladin training 4-6 could easily drop a good course of raid value, which is bad.

As I've said do make a proper and balance in the map and read tutorials for it.