Close Quarters

[Moderator]

14:52, 5th Sep 2011
-Kobas-:
Status: Rejected

 

[ksStr]

More screenshots will be better @@
How about map properties:
describing creep camps etc

Review
-You should change your map type to altered melee/mini games
+Doodas are good, enlarged, it gives a feel of jungle..
-too many red camps @@，in my opinion only..
-OMG with 3 level-3 jungle stalkers as green camp, thats kind a hard
-All red camps seems to be linked together...
-Oo extra gold mines...

 

[MrStormyZ]

More screenshots will be better @@
How about map properties:
describing creep camps etc

Review
-You should change your map type to altered melee/mini games
+Doodas are good, enlarged, it gives a feel of jungle..
-too many red camps @@，in my opinion only..
-OMG with 3 level-3 jungle stalkers as green camp, thats kind a hard
-All red camps seems to be linked together...
-Oo extra gold mines...

pretty much agreed with it
it's kind of an altered melee if it's not how the melee maps work.
by the way why not have a few more screenshots ?

 

[ksStr]

why maps now is moved into pending session@@
moderators will only review maps that people vote?

 

[MrStormyZ]

why maps now is moved into pending session@@
moderators will only review maps that people vote?

they're putting a new system for it, don't know much about it though.

 

[XPQJ]

too many red camps @@，in my opinion only..
-OMG with 3 level-3 jungle stalkers as green camp, thats kind a hard
-All red camps seems to be linked together...
-Oo extra gold mines...

its not a standard melee map, the twist of it is the no expansion, close bases, and hard creeps; the elements of the map create a different style of game-play, been noticing people playing these minigame style melee maps more then traditional melee map so I tried to make one.

 

[ksStr]

Okay =D
But still, you have to change map type to altered melee

 

[MrStormyZ]

Okay =D
But still, you have to change map type to altered melee

agreed again

 

[XPQJ]

meh done

 

[-Kobas-]

Before approval you need to fix:

• 12.500 gold per player without expansion mine is low!
• Pathing ground is bad, you must fill every single spot with pathing blockers, example I pick gargoyle and use stone form, it will land behind 1st line of pathing blockers making it unreachable for melee warriors (net, and such abilities will fail as well).
• Place trees near each other, to remove empty space between them where small unit can hide

 

[XPQJ]

I will fix soon sorry been really busy ;(

 

[Orcnet]

Close Quarters (No Version/s Stated)

Rating System:

Rating	Number	Percent	Letter
	5/5	91-100	A

Rating	Number	Percent	Letter
	4/5	81-90%	B

Rating	Number	Percent	Letter
	3/5	75-80%	C

Rating	Number	Percent	Letter
	2/5	70-74%	D

Rating	Number	Percent	Letter
	1/5	50-69%	F

Gameplay-[5/5]
Note: The playability and how it is entertaining in play.

Terrain-[5/5]
Note: View of the map's terrain.

Managing-[5/5]
Note: About the outcome of the game's mechanics.

Overview:

Gameplay

The Game was quite difficult to coupe with in the first game, creeps were unbearable because of lack of space and resources, their is none neutral buildings in the map including the tavern for those players who rely on neutral heroes, and again resources, gold mines are a must in the game, and the main gold mine are 120k? that would only get consumed for 15-20mins I guess.

Terrain

Terrain was love in the first site, I mean those wisp animations are interesting and unique way of adding a smooth atmosphere in the game, although your map needs more space, I can see your aiming the map with a beautiful specs that players would love to play with it, but as you can see, the passageways are a bit small.

Managing

For now I could say one thing, "needs more work". terrain was a good start with my observation and I like it, but after checkups of every race, map sections, etc. it really doesn't look like an altered melee, well perhaps of the neutral buildings that you took out eh? and I hope not.

Total Score:

Rating	Number	Percent	Letter
	7/15	73%	D

Status: Conditioned: Map needs more fixes

vm me after reading this review