BTNWine

[Moderator]

11:42, 19th Dec 2013
enjoy: The wine kind of looks too much like jelly? Water doesn't really splash like that, but I guess it's clear enough that this is wine.
Not very warcraftish. Nice icon, might be useful.
Gonna rate it recommended, due to the user ratings.

 

[Blood Raven]

This seems quite nice, but the wine looks a bit like blood. Maybe adding a little bit of magneta-like hue the wine has and darkening it might fix that.
Otherwise it looks great, 4/5 +rep

 

[Chaosy]

nice cartoonish look. I have to agree with BR tho. looks like blood.
4/5

 

[Panda]

Add some more "Wine" drips coming out of the barrel in the unused black space on the left side of the icon.

 

[Anachron]

I think the icon is perfect like it is now. Don't destroy it with more "drops".
I agree that it does not completely look like wine though. 4/5 and vote for approval.

 

[SpasMaster]

I think the icon is perfect like it is now. Don't destroy it with more "drops".

^
This.
Also, a very high quality icon over there. I really like it, keep it up! 5/5

 

[Roland]

Looks great! keep up the great work!

 

[stonneash]

Its a little wacraft II ish due to the cartoonish looking barrel but its icon itself is great.
4/5

 

[Mike]

Отличная иконка))

 

[Roland]

Отличная иконка))

I'm sorry, English please? :3

 

[Mike]

Roland, Excellent Icon)

 

[Roland]

Roland, Excellent Icon)

Well, I'm not the creator of this icon x)

 

[Mike]

Roland, No,no. I translated my words in English. "Отличная иконка" translated as "Excellent Icon". I wrote so because the creator and I from one country.

 

[Duhcake]

I think he meant the 'Roland' part as a reply to you, not saying you actually made the icon.

Looks real nice though~

 

[Kimbo]

Looks lovely, I plan to test and approve this when I get home.

Personal opinion? The barrel could be moved more towards the center, as there is alot of open space. But this has many uses as an icon

 

[knight820]

It's just rare to have a wine icon here.
5/5.