BTNStaff

[San]

Assuming the main presentation is the staff, you kinda overdid the effect on this one, the surrounding aura is getting more attention than the staff itself, which is awkward in my opinion.
Try stronger/higher saturation colors for the staff and a more pleasing colors for the effect so they don't blend together.
Take a look at Kimbo's Tutorial if you find the time, especially step 5 to 6 if you want to know more about aura drawing, it's easy to understand and in the same time a very useful tutorial.

 

[The Leader]

Assuming the main presentation is the staff, you kinda overdid the effect on this one, the surrounding aura is getting more attention than the staff itself, which is awkward in my opinion.
Try stronger/higher saturation colors for the staff and a more pleasing colors for the effect so they don't blend together.
Take a look at Kimbo's Tutorial if you find the time, especially step 5 to 6 if you want to know more about aura drawing, it's easy to understand and in the same time a very useful tutorial.

Thank you very much for your feedback! Soon I'll make update.

 

[San]

You should clean up the pixels when you have the time, they'll look better.

 

[San]

As a simple item, basic cleaning is required for this icon.
Leave a comment if you are not going to update this anymore.

 

[San]

Icon is not decent enough for approval in its current state.

 

[PrinceYaser]

@San Not sure if you noticed, but he has updated the icon. I think he would appreciate further review.

 

[Shar Dundred]

No need to tag him. Updated substandard or pending resources are moved back in the modding queue.

 

[PrinceYaser]

No need to tag him. Updated substandard or pending resources are moved back in the modding queue.

Understood.

 

[San]

Thanks for reminding me, Yaser.
---
About the icon, as I mentioned before; for better transition, you should avoid using black brush for shading and use darker shade of the object's color instead.
Since the handle is not visible anymore, it looks more a necklace than a staff. An aura of the same color from the object is not going good either.
You would probably need to reconsider the angle and proportion if you intend to present a staff with the model design.
We await further improvements.