BTNClothRose

[Moderator]

10:10, 6th Mar 2015
enjoy: Needs much more contrast (highlights and shading needed!)
You could center the rose a bit better.

17:20, 18th Mar 2015
Sin'dorei300: No changes made.
Awaiting update.

15:30, 28th May 2016
Sin'dorei300: Some changes have been made, but it still needs a bit of contrast(highlights and shadows).
Also, the green of the leaves could be darker, to better emphasize the bloom.

 

[Moy]

Needs backlight and a little shading in my own taste lol, looks really nice!
3/5

 

[Kingluis]

more light in the upper borders and shading between petals

 

[JollyD]

It has good shape but no real shadow and lights at all.
Here is what i have roughly done with 10 minutes editing.

I also have attached PSD file for u, so you can figure by yourself how to make something like that

 

[Kingluis]

*Sighs*
What do you know, look at your icons >.>
Please don't post just because.

Why so mean?

I perfectly know how my icons are and I am trying to improve

I am just trying to help the same way this community is helping me

 

[lokharke]

Now that you have gone past the point of first icon, a great tip would be what JollyD said. Some shading and color contrast is what you need to focus on. You have got no problem with presenting the icon conceptually and somehow your style doesn't differ much from the bigger picture to the smaller picture, which is good for now.

The leaves came out really well in the icon. I like yours better that JollyD's but that doesn't mean you can avoid shading.

 

[Sclammerz]

Looks nice!

 

[GhostThruster]

regarding both this and btnfabric: i can't see the previous versions, but the previous moderation feedback respective to each icon still applies.

add overall shading, increase contrast.

 

[Imadori]

Uh, but its pretty dark shaded already I think :\

Edit:
Ah silly me! The monitor I used here's dim. I'm trying to set it now but it's buttons isn't working.
Nevermind, I was going to upload two more icons but I guess that'll have to wait too until next month.
Thanks for the time GT~!

 

[Chaosy]

I'd say more shadowing would be better.
Basically, more contrast. (that's the right word, I think)

 

[GhostThruster]

planning to update these icons?

 

[Imadori]

Yep, I already talked with Sin. Sorry but it might take some time. I want to avoid updating them twice, cuz honestly I can't see if I adjusted them right at the current.

 

[Mgeterno11]

Looks nice, but some brighter colors would make it even better. Good luck. 5/5 to encourage

 

[Warseeker]

I kinda agree with the brighten aswell, I'd like if you could fellow the idea that JollyD said ^^