BTNBlueSword

[Moderator]

08:53, 6th Sep 2013
enjoy: I can't see that this is a sword. It looks like the blade is just a squarish point, like a pyramid? I can't see it. It's also very sqaure-ish looking. Not very warcraftish either. Also, you need to add highlights, and work on the shading. The blue color seems too bright blue.
Rejected.

 

[Binsu]

Hm, The appearance of the sword looks so cubify aand does not looks good. I would suggest aim for the original sword shape and form, might be hard but is worth it. If you did that, it might be more decent to look at and has chance of being approved. For now, 1/5. Sorry

But your effort wont go in vain, so here's a +4 REP for the effort

 

[Chaosy]

sorry to say that this is a bad icon. 1/5 I cant draw therefor I dont upload icons.

 

[stonneash]

I didn't really like this, it needs to be better, you can do better, I made you a basic tutorial attached if you interested in updating you Icon.
When you update your Icon I'll give you a proper Review and Probably rep.

 

[Mgeterno11]

Thanks for the suggestions. I will fix this icon. Stonneash, thanks for your tutorial.

 

[stonneash]

Thanks for the suggestions. I will fix this icon. Stonneash, thanks for your tutorial.

You so Welcome, if you need further more help I'm ready to offer everything I can do.

 

[Narandza]

Atc has higher quality...