Battle of Troll Homeland

[Moderator]

20:48, 24th May 2011
ap0calypse: This cannot be approved here.

 

[Vehster]

I barely played it, there is two upgrades that can't be researched which are in barracks and blacksmith and are marksmanship and the arrow icon one.

Improve description and fix author...
You need to add more.

 

[ap0calypse]

Races have barely been changed:

• Worker, Swordsman: only model file, icon, name, basic tooltip and soundset have been changed.
• Basically all buildings: nearly no changes. Sometimes a unit less, or a different upgrade, but that's where it ends.
• Structure of races hasn't been changed (the b asic techtree hasn't changed, you just changed the names and removed a few units/buildings from it).

Terrain isn't good:

• Emptiness, everywhere.
• Only 2 tilesets?
• The entire terrain is flat. Not a single hill (or attempt of a hill).
• Starting locations should be closer to gold mines.
• Random buildings in the middle are random.

Other:

• I hate the imported files. You do not need them, throw all custom recourses away that you do not need.
  If it doesn't fit your map, do not use it. No matter how cool it may seem, as simple as that.
• The creeps are too random. You don't use playable units for creeps either.
• No creep drops.
• An unprotected fountain of health...
• The map is way too big. At least 80% of the map is empty.

Do you really think I'd appreciate this map more just because it is your first?
Try practicing first. A map is rated on its quality, not on whether it's someone's first.