Battle of the Pelennor Fields v3.1

[ben_xuereb]

i have a friend that is making a battle of plennor fields his username is asasin850 i tested it twice with him is this the same one as he is making would you know him by any chance he is a LOTR fantic and hes realy good at making LOTR maps

 

[Rui]

I'm gonna download this to see what it look likes.

 

[ben_xuereb]

hmm i cant download it for some reason it says
cannot open file it does not appear to be to be a valid archive if you downloadd this file, try downloading it again

anyone know why and how i can fix this

 

[Rui]

I could download it. It's great! I just don't like the arthas' skin. I think it's kinda ugly >.<

But, the map itself is very good. Althrough I think you should reduce the damage of heroes. Heroes are like everything in the game. Also, give them complete abilities.

 

[Bob27]

Ben, that happens to me sometimes. You just download the map until it works. Don't download heaps of times though.

 

[Rui]

Ok. And btw i liked your way of protection. The map doesn't crash, you can open it but you can't steal anything from it. (That's kinda pity because I searched for that Darkwraith on dragon in the models section and I couldn't find it >.<)

 

[narsilflame]

Dark wraith on draogn is an attachment?

 

[Bob27]

no, its all 1 model. It should be some where on this site

 

[GhOsT50]

whoa! this maps models hmm ROCKED THE ****ING WC3 but it gets kinda lame after a while :twisted:

 

[Bob27]

I know it gets boreing after a while. I'll try and make a new version when I get my cpu fixed.

 

[teh_no_pwn]

overall good map compared to the other ones. keep up the good work!
P.S. wher'd u get that grond model?

 

[teh_no_pwn]

overall good map compared to the other ones. keep up the good work!
P.S. wher'd u get that grond model?

 

[hackhunter]

I WANT this to be a good game

Yo, got some pros and cons for yer.

Pros:
-Some Decent Skins
-Osgiliath and Minas Tirith are good looking
-Opening Cinematic
-All of the names are correct and there are no spelling mistakes
-Fairly Well Balanced

Cons:
-Gondor can attack the gates
-The gate towers should be given to a computer player and then shared with all Gondor Players
-Control is given to everyone at the start, and we know what happens when everyone has control over your units
-A few skins are pretty low quality
-The main gate should be invulnerable to everything except seige damage or invulnerable untill Grond enters the area
-Far too easy for Aragorn, Legolas and Gimli to get to the King of the Dead and defeat him because of all the soldiers
-Faramir was a tad too strong
-Rohan arrive too early into the game, they are hardly needed when they arrive.


Yeah, the Cons list is quite alot bigger, and this isn't feedback from just me other people have said this stuff aswell. This could be a majorly good game if you fix those things.
I'll try and get more feedback to you whenever I can.

 

[Bob27]

This is a very old map, so I am not sure if I will do any work on it, however I might take your suggestions into consideration and do some more work on it.

 

[hackhunter]

Please do!

I'd really like to see this map in a better way.