Arthas.blp

[Moderator]

15:03, 2nd Sep 2008
Hawkwing:
[Approved]
The quality of this texture is great. I suggest you change the design on the belt, it's a bit silly. But the texture is generally very well made.

 

[Hawkwing]

The armor is nice but the hair is lacking. Also, that mouth is a tad small.

 

[pyropk95]

ya i agree mouth is way minature...sweet wep though, although 665kb is a LOT for a skin

 

[Hawkwing]

Yes. It's quite big.

 

[Devine]

also blind? make a deaf one!!
face and hair needs work. rest looks really cool

 

[frostwhisper]

Face and hair are very blurry in my opinion. I suggest you work on those.

 

[knight26]

hes not gonna do much with wooden hammer u know everything else is nice.

 

[Lord_Firage]

Its a Magical wooden Hammer wuaahaha ...
BtT
Cool Skin !5/5

 

[Hawkwing]

Time for some real critique...

Negative Comments:

[-] Extremely high filesize.
[-] Mouth is small.
[-] Hair is blurry.
[-] I'm not too fond of the symbol on his belt buckle.
[-] Monotone book.
[-] Lacking Team Colour.
[-] Cape Highlights 'dodged' on.

Positive Comments:

[+] Lovely colours.
[+] Very high quality.
[+] Love that weapon.
[+] Very well done cape.
[+] Nice use of the wrap on that chest.
[+] Blindfold is well placed.

Comments: The filesize and mouth size are my biggest concerns, here.

Overall Rating: 4.2/5

 

[CombatTheWombat]

I ended up alphaing out the book, so you dun gotta wrry bout that

 

[Elfsilver Lord]

... im still loling about his belt buckle.

 

[Misha]

The armor is nice but the hair is lacking. Also, that mouth is a tad small.

When did Illidan change into a paladin?!?! Rofl!!! BTW that mouth is....gross. do some more rework.

And it has so much CnP as i see....

 

[Hawkwing]

I do not see ANY CnP whatsoever.

 

[The_Silent]

The only CnP i see is the mark in the corner.

 

[CombatTheWombat]

The book was cnp, but i alphaed that out so it doesnt matter. Everything else is freehand.

 

[Hawkwing]

I think the problem with the hair is that it's too flat and thick. Also, the strands are coming out of random spots. Try to make it all come from the front and make each strand of hair more visible.

 

[Deep Sea Kraken]

Actually Hawk, the model has team color, on his larger shoulder armor, theres a small TC foot-print. Should be made larger.

 

[Hawkwing]

My point is there isn't any heavily visible TC. And that is purerly translucent (alpha channels). Not even Blizzard uses it that bright. Cover it with 20% Opacity Black or something.

 

[terradont]

Yet another illidan? First theymake HD versions of him, now they make other characters into him...

Pretty blurry too, but at least you didn't CnP it.

Skin 3/5
Idea 1/5

 

[Lord_Firage]

Yet another illidan? First theymake HD versions of him, now they make other characters into him...

Pretty blurry too, but at least you didn't CnP it.

Skin 3/5
Idea 1/5

Noone said its Illidan ..It is a "NIGHTELF" Paladin
...
1/5 for the Idea ? Why 1 ? Its a nice Idea and you first have to get such ideas...

 

[X.e.r.e.X]

1/5 from idea?
This is unique shit ffs

 

[terradont]

My point is, the design clearly says it is Illidan, or a wannabe Illidan. All i'm saying is that the Illidan-worship is starting to get on my nerves.

With the Idea i meant the same thing, create a skin that looks like Illidan, it has been made several times before, that's why i give it such a low rate for idea. That is just an opinion that doesn't affect my actual rating on the skin.

Finally, making Arthas into a night elf is not very original. Tht too has been made several times before.

 

[madcat2]

My point is, the design clearly says it is Illidan, or a wannabe Illidan. All i'm saying is that the Illidan-worship is starting to get on my nerves.

With the Idea i meant the same thing, create a skin that looks like Illidan, it has been made several times before, that's why i give it such a low rate for idea. That is just an opinion that doesn't affect my actual rating on the skin.

Finally, making Arthas into a night elf is not very original. Tht too has been made several times before.

The only thing that looks like illidan is the blindfold the rest doesn't even look like a Illidan skin.

 

[Misha]

Noone said its Illidan ..It is a "NIGHTELF" Paladin
...
1/5 for the Idea ? Why 1 ? Its a nice Idea and you first have to get such ideas...

I did. (giggle)

 

[terradont]

Ok getting tired of all of this. It's my opinion that this was too much inspired from Illidan, and i said it. As i said, it does NOT affect my actual rating of the skin. It does not make it a bad skin, just the fact that i don't like it. i have even been generous, considering the file size.

1/5 for the Idea ? Why 1 ? Its a nice Idea and you first have to get such ideas...

Of coarse you need to get the idea first, but just as with skins there are good and bad ones, ya? And it's not a 0...

And even if you somehow would convince me that it doesn't resemble Illidan(please don't try), it still is Arthas as a Night Elf, which isn't very original as i said before.

Sorry if i angered some touchy people

 

[Master334]

Illadin was blind because (Something about demons?) and paladins are light right?

 

[Hawkwing]

Paladins are wielders of the Holy Light. Demon Hunters wear blind folds so they can see spirits and sense their surroundings better, or something like that.

The name isn't important. Just judge the apperance.

 

[CombatTheWombat]

It isnt Illidan retards, there, I said it. IDC if you think its unoriginal, I have never seen anyone do an arthas skin like this. AND There is plenty of team color. Perhaps rather than just looking at the screenshot you should download the skin and look at it so you can see the awesome TC design I did all over the cape.

 

[Misha]

It isnt Illidan retards, there, I said it. IDC if you think its unoriginal, I have never seen anyone do an arthas skin like this. AND There is plenty of team color. Perhaps rather than just looking at the screenshot you should download the skin and look at it so you can see the awesome TC design I did all over the cape.

I checked it. Ain't bad......but it might be better if you replace TC on the cape with some talon design and a bit thiner vines. 3.5/5 Nice.

Try to reduce the file size.

And yeah, do a screeny so everyone can see that TC up-close

 

[XtremeArthas]

It isnt Illidan retards, there, I said it. IDC if you think its unoriginal, I have never seen anyone do an arthas skin like this. AND There is plenty of team color. Perhaps rather than just looking at the screenshot you should download the skin and look at it so you can see the awesome TC design I did all over the cape.

and that :

Arthas--256 - The Hive Workshop - A Warcraft III Modding Site

the skin itself is very beautiful but a Paladin is not blind, doesn't at all a Night Elf Paladin
Skin the previous correponds more a Night Elf Paladin
and the file is much too heavy

 

[Fnorkus]

I think you need to upload a better screenshot.
Otherwise 4/5

 

[nickex]

Please change its name to night elf druid or night elf Warrior just for the story night elfs cant be Paladins

 

[terradont]

The name isn't really relevant for a skin. If you want to use it, change the name yourself?

 

[smoopa]

i guess i can use this for a druid i need...

 

[ELxCaigi]

Why are they allways blind!!!

 

[BrothForMyPeople]

Looks like Druid with wooden maul. Great.