Acw

[Moderator]

11:46, 1st Apr 2013
Orcnet: map has problems going on in-game, playing this in god mode cheat every hero in-game gains that cheat and can finish the game very quickly

also there is no trigger work where you cannot kill your ally unless its hp is in 20% of its existing life points that way you don't get problems from allies destroying your base as some sort of trolling business

most of the heroes are default spells and only a sinlge hero per race is customized with a different model and some random spells

anyways this map needs more attention about AoS maps do please tuts about it help from other users who knows much more about AoS and more.

 

[Daffa]

Daffa the Mage Map Review :

Terrain :
Nice terrain
Score : 5/5

Spells :
No Custom Spells, Boring..... Add some flavor to your map
Score : 0/5

Units :
Balanced, but they are lame without spells
Update : Still, Boring, good enough that you add more Hero to the game
Score : 4/5

Gameplay :
It's like DotA, and please note that I don't like DotA very much, except when using Certain Heroes. It's lame without custom spells, but still, it has a bit of originality
Update : Still, the same
Update : There is a ridiculous bug that whenever your Hero leave the shop, they get items like AI and loss their gold, fix this
Score : 0/5

Replayable :
I don't prefer to play the map much, it's boring with not much of Hero to choose and lame spells
Score : 0/5

Overall :
It needs tons of Improvements, although this map is a good map, improve it.

Total Score : 9/25

Converted Score : 1.8/5 Lacking - Vote for Rejection


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Suggestion :
-Fix the bug whenever one team loss their town hall all the other team wins (Suggestion has been Made)
-Create Custom Spells
-Create some Hero to choose (Suggestion has been made)
-Use BB Codes for description (I will reduce my rating by 5 points if you don't do this)
-Fix the Bug whenever your Hero leave the Shop, they get some items and loss their golds.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Score Table :

0.0-1.5 = Unacceptable - Vote for Rejection
1.6-2.3 = Lacking - Vote for Rejection
2.4-2.7 = Lacking - Vote for Approval
2.8-3.4 = Acceptable - Vote for Approval
3.5-4.2 = Recommended - Vote for Approval
4.3-4.7 = Highly Recommended - Vote for Approval and Recommended Map Section
4.8-5.0 = Director's Cut - Vote for Approval and Director Cut Map Section
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Second Request : If you wish me to re scored your map a second time please PM thank you.

 

[Daffa]

This map is no longer reviewed by me, my review is for version 1.0 (I think).

Due to lack of description, I won't review it anymore, I advise the author to use Map Description Generator on my Signature

 

[Binsu]

Just some tips to give, friend:
-Give more description to the map, a simple description like this will simply be rejected. Add some gameplay screenshots. I require you to use BB Codes and some Hidden tags.

-As what Daffa said, use Map Description Generator. It gives you a neat and nice description

Without playing this, I still vote for Approval but it can still be Rejected!

 

[Daffa]

Just some tips to give, friend:
-Give more description to the map, a simple description like this will simply be rejected. Add some gameplay screenshots. I require you to use BB Codes and some Hidden tags.

-As what Daffa said, use Map Description Generator. It gives you a neat and nice description

Without playing this, I still vote for Approval but it can still be Rejected!

Well, it doesn't matter wether we vote for approval or not, the Description is against the rules, thus Rejection is the only answer

 

[Orcnet]

map has problems going on in-game, playing this in god mode cheat every hero in-game gains that cheat and can finish the game very quickly

also there is no trigger work where you cannot kill your ally unless its hp is in 20% of its existing life points that way you don't get problems from allies destroying your base as some sort of trolling business

most of the heroes are default spells and only a sinlge hero per race is customized with a different model and some random spells

anyways this map needs more attention about AoS maps do please tuts about it help from other users who knows much more about AoS and more.