[4] Guardian River

[Moderator]

21:01, 28th Dec 2010
ap0calypse: Approved

 

[-Kobas-]

All your maps look so simple, you miss cliffs, I know that that isn't big deal but if you pick race other than night elf and + hire that goblin dude who can harvest up to 200 lumber, after 20 min map will be empty!

I think that you understand what I tried to explain

 

[Eldubs]

I know what you mean. Next time when i create a map, il make it a damn good map! Be ready in 10 minutes.

 

[-Kobas-]

lol map can't be good after 10 min
Some guys worked on melee maps over 1 year (well we are not so pro so we do it much faster, but I guess that you understand point)

 

[Eldubs]

Yeah, i watch simpsons at the same time when i create maps, does that affect it? ^^

 

[Shadow293903]

Meh, maybe. Lol.

(simpson's theme song going through head)

 

[Eldubs]

Any comments on the map?

 

[light bolt30]

I'm just wondering, has people who've created melee maps forgotten about the AI? They can never directly cut through trees to reach another place or use flying transport to transport units across sea or land. Also you got some grammar mistakes in your description.

 

[Eldubs]

Sorry my native language isnt english, can you point the mistakes out? And i usually make maps for players not bots : )

 

[DeadBoss]

I have check this Melee map. You should really try to use the tools Raise and Lower for making the terrain a little bit realistic, and add some cliffts it's too flat. About the doodads, i barrely saw doodads on the field. I will not vote untill you make this stuffs! Also i think this would be good for 2 players.

 

[Eldubs]

Players 2 or 4 : ), il do some work tomorrow, going to bed now.

 

[light bolt30]

You should always have 'i' as 'I' and when you wrote

I reall like this maps terrain my self

Did you mean " I really like this maps terrain my self "
dont should have a ' like this don't
I prefer this

and conquer your enemies by the upper hand!

as this " and conquer your enemies to gain the upper hand advantage! "

 

[Eldubs]

Thanks for the fixes, really appreciated! And i mistyped really xP

 

[Adiktuz]

when you make melee maps or altered melee maps, always make it a point that you make a good AI for it... ^_^

 

[Shaeam]

There really needs to be more decent melee maps on the hive, it's a dying genre sadly...

What I suggest to you is to use Dungeon trees on outland, looks alot better then the outland ones imho... Also it's hard to place my finger on it but something looks rather odd about the tile variation, and it seems that Red and Blue have slight advantages like being able to cut into the tree wall to the expansion quicker.

Other then that though I like it, 4/5.

 

[Eldubs]

There is a slight advantage, i will fix that in the next version. Also about the trees, il see what i can do about it also! Thanks for the suggestion!

 

[ap0calypse]

With a bit of raise/lowering the terrain, it could become okay.

The upper left island is a bit small though (it can easily be increased), I didn't really notice any major flaws so approval it is.
(Again: charged items!)