(2)Ashenvale Forest v1.1

[Moderator]

21:02, 18th Jun 2013
Orcnet:

Well there's a lot of problems with your map right now and that is too simple and monotone release of each field via game play, terrain landscape and totality of the map.

-The map is too wide, dirty looking, and so much space just for a 1v1 map.

-Terrain is flat and wide again, no much detail shown

-The expansion site with a gate and tree wall is just silly, trees can be killed by lumber harvest or siege damage so why need a gate?

-Creep camps are too far away, it looks good for now but a dragon camp with a dragon roost for a 1v1 is too imba

-It doesn't look like an altered melee, its more melee-like actually

So many things to do for this, practice or work yourself at map development thread.

 

[~DARK~]

~Reserved~ Delete My (2)Ashenvale Forest Please . Don't Delete This One This Is My Update One Delete The Old One

 

[Orcnet]

use this

not-obvious button instead, so I haven't tested this map, so wait for a neutral reply

 

[~DARK~]

Thanks For Your Help And Thanks For Your Testing My Map :X

 

[CroMoX]

Here we go

Good
- Some terrain areas such as the waterfall are quite good to look at

Bad
- Map is so empty
- The bases are way to small
- No use of raise and lower tool
- Gates will not work with AI
- Please change it to melee, since no units damage was changed (IDC what the editor says if you change size of units, or doodad information it is still melee)
- Not enough trees
- Gold mines all have the same amount in them

Suggestions
- Remove the gates
- FILL IN THE SPACE
- Use the raise and lower
- Increase base size

 

[Orcnet]

Well there's a lot of problems with your map right now and that is too simple and monotone release of each field via game play, terrain landscape and totality of the map.

-The map is too wide, dirty looking, and so much space just for a 1v1 map.

-Terrain is flat and wide again, no much detail shown

-The expansion site with a gate and tree wall is just silly, trees can be killed by lumber harvest or siege damage so why need a gate?

-Creep camps are too far away, it looks good for now but a dragon camp with a dragon roost for a 1v1 is too imba

-It doesn't look like an altered melee, its more melee-like actually

So many things to do for this, practice or work yourself at map development thread.