Approved
Moderator
M
Moderator
14:28, 27th Dec 2009
enjoy: This goes for all of them.
They are too cartoonish, especially the colors. And each of them doesn't resemble an element or anything. The idea is not very creative either. They lack proper highlights, shading and definition. I believe the dark grey part is the blade? That should look more like silver. Right now they look like plastic. I suggest you make only one of these icons, and do as I have suggested, and then delete the others.
- Rejected untill updated.
enjoy: This goes for all of them.
They are too cartoonish, especially the colors. And each of them doesn't resemble an element or anything. The idea is not very creative either. They lack proper highlights, shading and definition. I believe the dark grey part is the blade? That should look more like silver. Right now they look like plastic. I suggest you make only one of these icons, and do as I have suggested, and then delete the others.
- Rejected untill updated.
