The Idealists Challenge #2 Voting Poll

[sentrywiz]

Visit this thread first if you're here by accident. IC #2

Note that I only count valid votes from the remaining 12 participants.
No judges or third-party people. You can vote for fun.

 

[Templassassin]

Make rules here to tell the people that vote for IC for the first time

 

[sentrywiz]

Make rules here to tell the people that vote for IC for the first time

You mean other people besides participants? If they want they can vote.
But since this is a public poll, I will only count the votes from 12 participants into the final scores.

 

[Moy]

You should count all the votes except those self-vote (voting for self). And I thought it is a multi-voting since this will end on January 18 and there's so many entries.

 

[Sclammerz]

Subscribing and voting.

 

[Heinvers]

Good luck to the poll participants.

Btw shouldn't you add links to the entries so that people can judge easier and have a faster access to them?

 

[Sclammerz]

Good luck to the poll participants.

Btw shouldn't you add links to the entries so that people can judge easier and have a faster access to them?

This.

 

[Vinz]

Btw shouldn't you add links to the entries so that people can judge easier and have a faster access to them?

Link to the entries would be hard, since they are many. Plus they could be easily accessed from the first post anyways. Speaking of, the link goes to page 25, not page 1.

 

[sentrywiz]

You should count all the votes except those self-vote (voting for self). And I thought it is a multi-voting since this will end on January 18 and there's so many entries.

Why would it be multivoting? There are 12 entries, and each gets 1 vote.
So that's... 12 votes total?

Link to the entries would be hard, since they are many. Plus they could be easily accessed from the first post anyways. Speaking of, the link goes to page 25, not page 1.

Fixed.

 

[Daffa]

Only contestant votes count?

Anyway, choose Raza'rr since he wons my vote, must admit in graphical it's great and has a good synergy, though I kinda dislike the escaping style, but it's still great.

 

[Sclammerz]

I voted Raza'rr cause' it's ***. Anyway it's graphics really stand out.

 

[sentrywiz]

Only contestant votes count?

Anyway, choose Raza'rr since he wons my vote, must admit in graphical it's great and has a good synergy, though I kinda dislike the escaping style, but it's still great.

In my mind public vote means contestants voting. I don't know if this means ALL and ANY random members that vote. Because that would be OP. Someone can ask all of their friends to vote for him and get a superior advantage in the score. 25% isn't much, but hey it might beat you to top 3.

 

[Vinz]

That's prohibited in the official contests... and yet it is happening right now. I pass my opposition on this subject, because for once, it's something new. Let's just discount self votes, that's my opinion.

My vote goes to Raz'arr.

 

[Moy]

I just gave numbers, but I reviewed some but then I became bored. I will probably post the full scoring without any comments.

So my vote goes to, Malendis.

 

[Daffa]

In my mind public vote means contestants voting. I don't know if this means ALL and ANY random members that vote. Because that would be OP. Someone can ask all of their friends to vote for him and get a superior advantage in the score. 25% isn't much, but hey it might beat you to top 3.

Fair enough, I just ask some out of my friend list to vote me if you allow such thing (just joking, not gonna even if you did). Good thing you didn't, as it avoids superior advantages for certain members.

 

[GreeN!X]

I would have voted for everyone but since I can't, I just voted for the very first entry so that I can easily see the poll results.

Is self voting counted? If not, then what if most of the contestants voted for themselves? Wouldn't that result in (almost) everyone getting no votes?

 

[Fang]

Can I vote my own hero?

 

[Chaosy]

#voted

Too bad I don't count.. yet..

 

[Daffa]

Can I vote my own hero?

If I recall right, it doesn't count. I'll let Sentrywiz answer this though, in case he changed the rules.

 

[Chaosy]

That has never been allowed in any contest

 

[sentrywiz]

Can I vote my own hero?

If I recall right, it doesn't count. I'll let Sentrywiz answer this though, in case he changed the rules.

Self voting results in nothing really. If everyone votes for their own hero once, we all end up with same percentages of votes.

So while I don't see how bad it is, its not beneficial either.

 

[Vinz]

Because that's considering if everyone does so. But if only few do, there is a difference.

But I won't oppose much though. Something new.

 

[sentrywiz]

Because that's considering if everyone does so. But if only few do, there is a difference.

But I won't oppose much though. Something new.

True.

7/12 people voted. 5 to go.

Of course if the rest don't vote until the end of the poll, I'll just take the scores as they are.

Btw Nightmare share the score formula with me again. Was it Poll Score + Judge 1 / Judge 2 score?

 

[Moy]

For more accuracy, the formula is below:

SCORE = (P * .25) + ([(J1 + J2)/2] * .75)

Where
P = Poll Percentage
J1 = Judge #1
J2 = Judge #2

I'm a math genius

EDIT:
Aw,
To get the reall Poll Percentage of an entry, here's the formula:
PP = (VV / NPV) * 100

Where:
PP = Poll Percentage
VV = Valid Votes gained (excluding the votes from the non-participants)
NPV = No. of participants WHO voted.

 

[sentrywiz]

Okay, so Fang, dhika axe, Edge45 haven't voted so far.

Looks that Blade Tempest has the most votes so far.

EDIT: I sent a message to each of them that haven't voted.
Hopefully they will until tomorrow. If they don't it looks like
the public has their "champion" decided upon.

 

[Moy]

11/12 Fang vote please

 

[Dreadwing]

Voted for The Blood of Gore:

Wolf *Check
Blood *Check
Evil/Scourge *Check
Awesome **Double Check

Btw, I don't know poll is already opened...

 

[sentrywiz]

Okay everyone voted.

Now I await the judges scores.

 

[Sclammerz]

That was a fast poll.

 

[sentrywiz]

That was a fast poll.

3 days is more than enough to... click a button.

 

[Vinz]

You're both right, you know how.

 

[Chaosy]

I got one entry left to judge. However I will likely tweak a few of the first reviews since I changed my mindset after noticing a few things. I guess you could call it experience. ;P

 

[Moy]

So tomorrow, there will be results already?

 

[jopi]

well, I have to admit I'm far from being as done with the ratings as Chaosy.
I'm judging all entries paralelly , means I've already did the ratings for all entries for 'concept','lore' and 'presentation' but the other categories still have to be done.

Also I was ill the last few days so I've the ratings later than expected, as I also had to wait dor all entries to be finished.

I hope I'm done with my ratinngs within the next 2-3 days, please forgive me that you have to wait, but I'm also only human^^

 

[sentrywiz]

well, I have to admit I'm far from being as done with the ratings as Chaosy.
I'm judging all entries paralelly , means I've already did the ratings for all entries for 'concept','lore' and 'presentation' but the other categories still have to be done.

Also I was ill the last few days so I've the ratings later than expected, as I also had to wait dor all entries to be finished.

I hope I'm done with my ratinngs within the next 2-3 days, please forgive me that you have to wait, but I'm also only human^^

but I'm also only human^^

How dare you, you... you... HE-MAN!

Take your time. I'm also sick so idk if I'll even be bothered to actually tweak the bbcodes that much to add your scores.