13:46, 17th Oct 2009
enjoy: Add some more highlights to the handle, and then blend out the definition alittle, so it isn't so rough.

enjoy: The blade is blurry. define it more.

enjoy: I think you should start over :/ Get inspiration from other icons maybe, to how they make the shading and such, to give sharp edges ect. ect.

Looks quite good but isnt the shape of the gem a little wierd?
Anyways, good job on this icon. Keeo up the good work.

the handle is off centre. a stronger red glow will be advisable i think, in order to define the sword outline

That looks...brilliant.
I think the handle should be smaller, i can't see much of the blade.

The handle's pretty good, but the blade is lopsided.

i think its too straight... and the handle is a lil to big

Thanks for comments. Will work on what you have said :3

Darkmoon Hero, what does lopsided mean? sorry :s

Edit: Updated!

Pyramidhe@d said:

the handle is off centre.

Click to expand...

Sorry. This is what I meant.

Updated!

Updated again

the soft shadings on the blade makes it look like the sword is cylinderical

Pyramidhe@d said:

the soft shadings on the blade makes it look like the sword is cylinderical

Click to expand...

Agree ^^ handle is great. Make smudging line at center of blade or something

And the glow! Why are the glows always a dull red :/

The sword is fantastic However, the background and glow need to be a little more defined

All in all though, great job!

So fucking pissed right now. I've been working on a chestpiece for this Red Gem set, and it was really turning out awsome, and then Gimp decides to shut down. Could seriously kill someone >.<

I will update the glow, thanks all

Edit: Updated. Remade most of the glow.

fine work. but outline it more. it also misses some shading...

Now it is Jedai sword
Rly, defne blade by placing some line at center of it. also shade sides diferent.

that looks quite nice 4/5

Everyone else has basically said the adjustments, But nice sword.