13:37, 14th Aug 2009
zombie2279: Honestly, the only fitting thing I see is the color scheme, the rest is quite simple and lacking. First of all, it doesn't really look like a napalm bomb effect, it looks like a simple explosion. I'd advise you to do a simple burning ground effect if you want to point out it's actually napalm. If you want to stick to the explosion effect, add something exploding and add more colors to the whole thing, otherwise it's too simple. Use red, yellow, darker orange tones. You could also add particles flying. Note that these are just recommendations, you don't have to follow them, but you do have to come up with more details if you want this to get approved.

Rejected until updated.

Although it looks pretty easy to make, the overall concept of the icon [which I think it's the most important part] is well made. The only thing though the whole blast thing could be lowered back behind so we see more of a half-sphere instead of the ball we see here.

Could also be used as a sunset if you would be out of better sunsets

Somnium said:

Although it looks pretty easy to make, the overall concept of the icon [which I think it's the most important part] is well made. The only thing though the whole blast thing could be lowered back behind so we see more of a half-sphere instead of the ball we see here.

Could also be used as a sunset if you would be out of better sunsets

Click to expand...

Got it.

I think it looks very nice.

Looks like a sun rise, but it looks good so far i would make it have a firework theme. Have the firework come up and then have the blast effect you have on the icon now when the firework explodes.