BTNArcaneconundrum

Moderator · Apr 5, 2009

13:02, 6th Apr 2009
Paladon:

Icon Review

Creativity: 3/5
Quality: 6/10
Status: Rejected until updated
Comment: Please remake the hand. The fingers are very thin and the hand appears unshapely. Otherwise it's okay.

NiddHogg-kun · Apr 5, 2009

as this is your first icon please show us WIP

Pharaoh_ · Apr 5, 2009

Sorry for sounding such a noob, but i don't really get what you want me to show you. :I

Justify · Apr 5, 2009

A big version of this, meaning the original picture you draw before resizing it

Pharaoh_ · Apr 5, 2009

I draw no picture. It is made out of pure photoshop objects, it is not based on any render. If this is required, i can send the psd file to a moderator i guess. Plus, it is not resized, it is directly made into the 64x64 size.

NiddHogg-kun · Apr 5, 2009

i dont really think this is possible to make in 64x64 size

well could you send me please PSD

Devine · Apr 6, 2009

NiddHogg-kun said:
i dont really think this is possible to make in 64x64 size

well could you send me please PSD

It is possible.

I'd like to see the PSD file ...
the layers'll be the proof.

Pharaoh_ · Apr 6, 2009

Honestly, it is made within the 64x64 image; no resize at all. All done with zoomed 64x64. For the *.psd file, i will give it only to a moderator that requires it, since it's my first icon, but still, i don't think sharing the work is fair enough; i mean, everyone had his first job, did moderators asked for the work itself?

Justify · Apr 6, 2009

Pharaoh_ said:
Honestly, it is made within the 64x64 image; no resize at all. All done with zoomed 64x64. For the *.psd file, i will give it only to a moderator that requires it, since it's my first icon, but still, i don't think sharing the work is fair enough; i mean, everyone had his first job, did moderators asked for the work itself?

And I think it's okay like this.
Only moderators need to see the psd

Devine · Apr 6, 2009

The fingers should en like this <)
not like this =>

Pharaoh_ · Apr 6, 2009

Don't get your designs, but the shape is exactly as it is supposed to be. It might be the shadow that confuses you. Everything is in the right order/direction.

BTNArcaneconundrum

BTNArcaneconundrum (Icon)

Moderator

Moderator

NiddHogg-kun

NiddHogg-kun

Resources

Pharaoh_

Pharaoh_

Resources

Justify

Justify

Resources

Pharaoh_

Pharaoh_

Resources

NiddHogg-kun

NiddHogg-kun

Resources

Devine

Devine

Resources

Pharaoh_

Pharaoh_

Resources

Justify

Justify

Resources

Devine

Devine

Resources

Pharaoh_

Pharaoh_

Resources

Similar threads