So, by now I have actually played Arathor on w3c a few. I didnt notice anything that I would say needs to be changed or improved. As iirc I already mentioned in discord, the map really nails the Arathi Basin look from wow.
-Overall at first glance the map is somewhat unspectacular, with all the basics being done right. There isnt an obvious standoud feature, but it seems that in the lategame the game will often be decided by whoever manages to occupy the middle, which has interesting strategic implication, similar to Murgul Oasis only among the 4v4 maps.
-There really arent many creeps, only 4 camps (of which most orange ones dont even give too much exp). I wont count the creeps on all 4v4 maps, but I wouldnt be surprised if it has the lowest amount of experience of all current 4v4 maps. On second thought, maybe this could be called a standout feature.
-Also no two starting position on each team are the same, but imo in practice it wont make much of a difference.
-Having lvl 2 charged items drop from lvl 6 creeps is unusual and feels a little underwhelming as a reward. For 1v1 I wouldnt recommend this, but here on a 4v4 maps it's not an issue.
-I would like to have a shredder available for convenience, but it's no must-have. Maybe labs could be nicely placed at the central Murgul/Murloc spot, so that the middle would also be more relevant early on?
-For non-4v4 gameplay, the creeps at the yellow starting position are still missing the lvl 2 powerup
That's all for now. Map
approved.
Also, ofc official congratulations for getting the map into the wc3 map pool :=)