I prefer the first screen, if you zoomed in a tiny bit more. Couple of things:
-As Gilles said, add some plant variations, also tree variations, I suggest using fur trees with which you can go wild from purple to black.
-Also like Gilles said add tile variaton, however; you should change the tileset with some grass unlike the repetitive highlighter green LS grass. For example, Ashenvale Dirty grass and Sunken Ruins Dark Grass make a quite good blend, I think, or just Village Grass and short grass + Ruins dark grass.
-For the foreground, either: Expand on your camping place
or
Leave out the foreground by zooming in a tiny bit
more.
-As Gilles said, the road - whatever the hell it's made of - ends very abruptly, I'd suggest either making it into a bridge over the river or a tunnel into the mountain.
-Your sky doesn't fit, I suggest simply using the generic one instead of LW.
-I think you should spice the water up with something, like a ship or a few fishing boats + nets, maybe even a small island.
But overall, it's a good start.