Valley of Darkness

[johannesr]

I've got 3 versions of this terrain, which one's the best in your opinion? Also comment on them in general.

 

[66Dragon6]

2nd one, better distribution

7/10

 

[Sheephunter]

Scary! I like it alot, screen 2 looks the best tho, cuz its not to dark, not to light and you can see something on it to

 

[PROXY]

me loves all three

 

[Bernkastel]

First of all.. What's that roof doing there? and then about the pictures

-The first picture, it's nice but the background is too dark (the clouds)
-The second picture, Must be the best because the background is right colored and adds a nice feeling to the picture
-The third picture, I'd love it but well.. The clouds cower the moon behind them.. That's the only thing that i dont like in it.

So second picture wins :3

 

[Arcany]

First of all, this an awesome terrain, somehow it really manages to capture my attention.

I got to say that the first version is by far the best, it portrays a superb atmosphere with just the right amount of lighting/fog/clouds.
The 2nd and 3rd version kind of screw up the atmosphere because the background is too white and thus jumps out too much, these types of terrain should be gloomy, dark and monotonous. Making anything jump out too much gravely diminishes the quality of the terrain.