The Sunken City

[Moderator]

» Vengeancekael:[c] 「Profile :: Message :: Hive Staff」

» Date:[c] 「24/Feb/2013 03:05:35」

» Reasons:

​

​

» Comment:

Atmospheric, but generic feel and nothing new.
Goblin merchants are always welcome.
[Moderated version: IV]
[Rating change: 2/5 -> 3/5]​

​

Acceptable

[tr]​

» Rules: [c] 「Map Submission」

» Contact: [c] 「Staff Contact」

_{! 'Reasons' are automated !}

Old review

Vengeancekael - [Contact]
Date: 2012/Jun/03 15:40:29

Comment: [Approved]
Neat, very atmospheric map, but like sonofjay has suggested, add more grass, I'd even suggest you use those dark animated grass models from UTM.
And add a higer level item drop to the level 6 rock golems, level 1 power ups should be given to green/yellow camps.
Add goblin merchants to the left and right side of the map (yellow camps).
Right now it's acceptable though.

Resource Moderation - Rules

 

[dontcryman]

..

so? its like any melee map

 

[sonofjay]

@dontcryman, what do you mean?

 

[Remixer]

@dontcryman, what do you mean?

@dontcryman, I did not get that neither. And it is not. There is no melee map like this. And try to seek all the blizzards melee maps that are made with Dalaran Ruins tileset and have way gates. Good luck...

 

[bamq]

Great

This map is awesome. I think that the fog looks nice and the Way Gates were a good idea.

I seems to me that the bottom-left area has more room to build than the top-right.

 

[sonofjay]

Well I don't have a big spare time to make a full review

GOOD:

• The waygate is a great idea
• A fair and symmetric terrain.

BAD:

• Don't put a rock golem in a group of kobold. Golem and kobold have no relation to each other.
• A level 3 kobold drops a level 5 items but a level 4 water elemental drops a level 2 item?
• The lower player have more space to build.

RATING: 2/5 Vote for approval

Other notes: Just improve the item drops and make the base wider so players have more space to build.

 

[Remixer]

Updated! Take a look at change log!

 

[sonofjay]

Better, but I still have some suggestions, try adding some more shrubs or anything since its looks empty on some areas.

After that I'll change my rating to 3/5

 

[Remixer]

Map Major Update!

The map has been updated, the layout has stayed the same but creeps and tile variations has been changed as well as trees.

The maps theme has experienced a huge change.

 

[SpasMaster]

lol

 

[deepstrasz]

-funny thing is that heroes and other units may enter the Way Gates without the neutral hostile attacking but when trying to get back from the islands those neutrals near the gates start the attack

 

[Destery]

I agree with the review. But aside from that, this melee is unique; I haven't really seen a style like this, or am I low standard? Either way, I, too, have some suggestions but that'll take a whole new update. Thumbs up, tho!