Here we have a special Shido bundle dedicated to our very own
@frostwhisper which I think is a very nice gesture, let's take a look:
The Good:
Three textures all in the one bundle is great for anyone wanting a complete set of units, so we have the hero and two unit textures.
Thematically the ice theme is pretty good and works well with the Icy Centaur and Cold Garithos textures that we saw before. The units looks suitably icy and have lots of details enhancing the cold Ice Troll idea, so props there.
There is shading and highlighting which is good with light falling on the shoulders and arms and face with darker areas in regions that will be lower down or more concealed on the textures.
We also have some cool effects like the glowing eyes across all three which look good. And the slight pinkish colouration on the bone mask adds a lot to the bone look and feel. The ice crystals have for the most part been drawn really well and are visibly crystals so the material look has been achieved there.
One of the stand out parts in my opinion is the mask of the Shadow Hunter; its a shame it's not present on the original model and requires the Beta model cos the mask looks phenomenal:
the red central plank of the wood especially looks great and the gold rims have been done really well. It's stylistic but well executed.
EDIT: Icons are always a big plus in my book!
Areas for Improvement:
This is a tricky one as whilst there is a lot of effort and variation across all three textures, I find there's a lot of inconsistency in the quality which is a shame as you've done similar sections really well and then maybe rushed over other bits. I'll give some examples. The fur loinclothes and fur looks good in areas like here:
and here:
but then in other areas there is a distinct lack of the folds, shading etc necessary to convey that same cloth look and we instead just get a brown flat shape like here:
and here:
there is some shading but they need more work to look more like the previous two bits. The fur lining also looks good shape wise but needs more shading to make it look fluffy.
The same applies to the various crystals and hair where it's been done really well in some areas like here:
and here:
but then there are sections that are quite large and lack the same look and quality such as these bits:
and these bits:
The skin as well is done a lot better in some parts vs others. I think there's a lot of skill on display here but it just needs to be consistent across all the parts of all the textures. Consistency is key
Conclusion:
A very fitting tribute to frostwhisper with a lot of nice theme and drawing work on display here. I do really like these textures but I think more time is needed to ensure the quality is the best it can be across all the texture space! Still some very lovely skins that are easily approved!