I decided to make a new topic for this, the main reason is the other one wasn't built to discuss spoilers but rather expectations of the game and as I want to speak really heavy spoilers people should know what to expect. If the story got spoiled remember it was in the title so you've got only yourself to blame. So as you might have figured out from the title I find the Witcher III to be more than just a little disappointing. The reason for that is one of the main selling points of the trilogy is how much difference your choices make and quite frankly I find that to be rubbish. If we look at all the characters whom you can choose to kill of. (Queen) Saskia: Neither Saskia nor Upper Aeidern are even mentioned. On a map we can see that this land has been conquered by Nilfgaard but no mentions of Saskia is made. Síle de Tanserville: Síle dies in her cell 30 seconds after you meet her highly disappointing and her life has next to no impact on the third game. King Henselt: If you spare Henselt you later find out that he was killed and his lands were conquered by Radovid so if you let him live or if you kill him has no impact on the story either. Aryan La Valette: If you spare Aryan you will not have the chance to rescue his mother Mary Louisa La Valette. If she's still rotting in the dungeons however she manages to escape on her own once again removing the value from your choice. Letho: I've played this game 5 times and I never spared Letho as I found him too boring, whereas he is a puppet Síle is a puppeteer hence I spared her and not him. Iorveth: You get to decide whether to side with Iorveth or Roach and this is the most important decision in the second game as it decides how the rest of the game plays out yet Iorveth is not seen or heard from once. In conclusion, my opinion is that the game does not deliver what it has promised and I bought this game expecting to see that choices mattered as was promised yet it was not delivered. What do you think of the Witcher III, are you as disappointed as I am?