Siege Island v2

[Moderator]

Orcnet

19:28, 21st Dec 2013

---

Siege Island (Tested Version 1.5) Rate Score Percent Letter 5/5 91-100 A Rate Score Percent Letter 4/5 81-90% B Rate Score Percent Letter 3/5 75-80% C Rate Score Percent Letter 2/5 70-74% D Rate Score Percent Letter 1/5 50-69% F Overview: Gameplay "The game is swift and very true to quick deaths rather than earning your way through an arena theme, most of the heroes were based on DotA's allstar champions. The winning bonus of this map is that it has functioning AI that tracks and kills which is a cool feature." Terrain "Terrain is really different and has a really good look into it, however the global terrain work is just made on a same level, if there was cliff levels and shallow water regions it could shape up a good gaming ground." Management "Overall map can recommended, you should work on that music/sound trigger its very noisy with the default theme and the rock n roll music mixing in, plus give in a quest menu on how to play, commands, updates, and reports of the game." Total Score: (Gameplay[x/5] + Terrain[x/5] + Management[x/5] / Total Score[15] * 50 + 50) Rate Score Percent Letter 9/15 80% C

 

[Mech_Warrior]

Hey Hitokiri_Vanguard,

Wow I'm very impressed! This map is lots of fun. Played it with 6 people on bnet, and we all had fun.

A few comments in general:

A lot of the heroes require knowledge of DotA, which isn't necessarily bad, but something to keep in mind when introducing completely new heroes to the game, as people may expect them all to be DotA-based.

Some of the abilities don't really require a lot of skill to use. ie: The freeze custom (not Crystal Maiden, the guy who locks your hero in and damages them) and the ninja guy. Not necessarily a bad thing, but it can be frustrating for the enemy if they just point-and-click to kill you.

Also a minor thing, in your map name on the Hive you have it spelled "seige" but in the game's load screen it is spelled "siege." I believe per North American convention, siege is correct; might wanna just stick to that spelling.

Overall a really fun arena, when I had all but given up on arenas. 5/5 rating. Good work!

 

[kenegeneget13]

thx for playing it
BTW any suggestions you want to see in the next update?

 

[twistedfate08]

NIce

 

[kenegeneget13]

why its still in pending??

 

[chobibo]

It has to be reviewed by the moderators first, before it gets approved, that's why it's still pending. Just relax and be patient, they have other things to do too, like all of us.

 

[kenegeneget13]

oh i see )

is it ok to update it while the map is in pending??

 

[chobibo]

Yeah. Please do.

 

[kenegeneget13]

if i made an update i will write it on a changelog right??

Updated!!

update 1.2

update 1.3

see changelog for more info

update 1.4

update 1.5

 

[Binsu]

The Hive Workshop Official

Map Reviewer: Hell_Master Map Name: Siege Island v1.1 Map Author: kenegeneget13 Originality I have seen such maps like this so for me, this is quite a common game though I like the modes present in the game which makes it better and unique though most of the heroes in-game are present in the DotA game. Score: 56/100 Presentation Presentation is really neat and attractive. I must say, a job well-done. It is a neat presentation giving viewers all the possible basic information to know about the game. No BB Codes errors or spelling errors. Given how simple is the description yet it still looks neat and much more informative so this gets a perfect score from me. Score: 100/100 Design Map Preview and Loading Screen looks awesome and fitting for this type of map. Tooltips looks much fine and no broken or green icons in-game. Though some names are mispelled or should we say some little errors in grammars such as Dispell, it should be dispel. There are more in-game though can't remember the others. Score: 70/100 Terrain Terrain looks neat and great to be honest though it could have some height variations. Use the Raise/Lower tool to do the trick and also, you might also want to consider making the trees bigger. Nothing much to say, the terrain is just good. Score: 65/100 Triggers I am not much of the person to judge triggers so I'll just go simply with nice job and I can say that the triggers is really neat and well-documented or well-arranged. Score: 100/100 Object Data Everything looks fine and I can say, nothing wrong with scaling sizes, selection sizes though it could be better if all hero could get a Hero glow model. Abilities are fitting for each unit. Score: 79/100 Gameplay Gameplay is really fast paced and it is great to have some quick matches in this game though the Storm Mode of the game could have more of a hint on where thunder would pop up like putting up an aura at the striking point so its not just based on pure luck. Also, could use some more items and most likely heroes. Score: 68/100 Terrain could have some height variations. Use the Raise/Lower Tool to do the job Trees could be bigger to be realistic because having trees with sizes of heroes is quite unrealistic. Some heroes could have a hero glow model Thunders that strikes random points could be more not based on pure luck. Make a hint on where th thunder will aappear to give chances of dodging. This is on Storm Mode by the way. Final Score: 76.857/100 4/5 Vote for Approval Contact: (Visitor Message) / (Private Message) / (Map Reviewers)

 

[Orcnet]

Map approved, see moderator comment on top.

 

[kenegeneget13]

Thank You so much @Moderators

 

[ukn0wnD3str0y3r]

I suggest you to change those ability key onto [Q] and [W], it is more easier to remember and uses :3

 

[ukn0wnD3str0y3r]

Finally is Upgrade!
EDIT: Updated* xD

 

[kenegeneget13]

Finally is Upgrade!
EDIT: Updated* xD

Any Suggestion to see in the next update?