Should I submit this?

[Magtheridon96]

Since a lot of you know me even more than I know myself, I'm going to tell you: No. This isn't a Jass resource.

My request is:
- I want you to tell me whether I should convert this to an icon and submit it to the Icons section or not.

I've had a bad history with the Icons section, so I find it appropriate to ask people here.

edit

[00-28-33] enjoy: Magtheridon96, It doesn't look like wood, it looks like cracked earth from a hot desert. The leafs shape is also wrong and you use way to thick lines. The colors are wrong aswell. I suggest looking at some tutorials. You need to learn to shade and highlight properly as well.
[00-29-12] Magtheridon96: enjoy, That's why I'm calling an EarthWand
[00-29-18] Magtheridon96: enjoy, it an*
[00-30-18] Magtheridon96: enjoy, And yeah, even after reading maybe 5 or 6 tutorials, I still can't highlight or shade right :C
[00-30-22] enjoy: Magtheridon96, lol.. "Doesn't look like wood. Changes the name to make it fit"
[00-30-25] enjoy: I do not approve of that.
[00-30-38] enjoy: Magtheridon96, It takes a lot of practice

/Thread.
I'll go practice now.

 

[eubz]

Well, it looks good to me. You only need borders for it dude, and try scaling it down if that is not yet scaled down. I have no Photoshop here so I use my google sketch up to see the painting of yours.

 

[Magtheridon96]

I know it looks good, but enjoy doesn't like it, and the leaves suck, so I have to redraw it