Shadow City

[Moderator]

you only changed tile set and no remakes at all

 

[-SmaSHeR-]

Rate & comment
will add screenie later

Edit: added screenie

 

[Binsu]

Actually, it is not an issue afterall for many users done this. It is a type of reserve for users if they have more to write.

By the way, will be playing this now!

 

[Binsu]

what a bad habit, when i was in an anime forum, this issue was forbiden
if someone want say more, there was two ways, edit the post or wait to someone post.

But he can only post up to there and posting more than 2 is considered bad.

 

[Binsu]

ok if Godsmasher do that, i will be quiet (because the woman walking upstairs)

She will butt attack you. XD

 

[Binsu]

Played your map also and this looks good and approvable at its state. Here is my review:

[+] Good Points:
-Terrain is good. Terrain is not flat anymore and it has a fitting fog but mostly your probelms are lack of doodads mostly environmental doodads and also at many points you didnt mix some tiles to make it better
-Map has required resources:

• Gold Mines
• Goblin Labaratory
• Goblin Merchant
• Mercenary Camp
• Tavern

-Players are well positioned in the map
-Creeps are balanced enough

[-] Bad Points:
-None

[] Suggestions:
-Some minor terrain improvements.
-Better add a fountain also

Overall, good melee map with good terrain, required resources and balanced creeps and such. Rated 4/5 and +4 REP to you.

Voting for Approval!

 

[Binsu]

i won you in review for seven minutes, that was close Hell Master

Actually I am not competing or racing with you :b

 

[CroMoX]

[] Suggestions:
-Some minor terrain improvements.
-Better add a fountain also

Just saying not every map has to have a fountain, including one like this where there is water separating people, and will not be used as much as a map without water

 

[Binsu]

Just saying not every map has to have a fountain, including one like this where there is water separating people, and will not be used as much as a map without water

Suggestion can be meant to deny so its okay if he didnt add it.

 

[-SmaSHeR-]

Played your map also and this looks good and approvable at its state. Here is my review:

[+] Good Points:
-Terrain is good. Terrain is not flat anymore and it has a fitting fog but mostly your probelms are lack of doodads mostly environmental doodads and also at many points you didnt mix some tiles to make it better
-Map has required resources:

• Gold Mines
• Goblin Labaratory
• Goblin Merchant
• Mercenary Camp
• Tavern

-Players are well positioned in the map
-Creeps are balanced enough

[-] Bad Points:
-None

[] Suggestions:
-Some minor terrain improvements.
-Better add a fountain also

Overall, good melee map with good terrain, required resources and balanced creeps and such. Rated 4/5 and +4 REP to you.

Voting for Approval!

Aha nice one
you still need to give 4+4 if you know what i mean

 

[Binsu]

Aha nice one
you still need to give 4+4 if you know what i mean

Yes, the limit keeps stopping me from doing so.

 

[THe Sandro]

OMG you make meele maps so fast
5/5

 

[-SmaSHeR-]

OMG you make meele maps so fast
5/5

Its easy to make meele maps
you just make terrain
place some units and decorations

 

[Binsu]

Its easy to make meele maps
you just make terrain
place some units and decorations

Ok, gave you your +4 REP for doing once again a good melee map. =)

4 more to go for that last map I reviewed...

 

[TaShadan]

nice. You should make an island map or semi island

 

[-SmaSHeR-]

nice. You should make an island map or semi island

I have maps based on island check my profile

 

[TaShadan]

I know but i mean broodwar or warcraft 2 style island maps, where ships can be of use.

 

[-SmaSHeR-]

I know but i mean broodwar or warcraft 2 style island maps, where ships can be of use.

I'll consider that

 

[Orcnet]

this map is very similar to the blizzard map Sanctuary of the frozen throne
you did changes, but you didnt say nothing in the description

consider this map removed now