Approved
Map Reviewer
- Joined
- Nov 2, 2013
- Messages
- 869
Hello!
"Melee" map on the hiveworkshop generally should be understood as "map that offers unaltered gameplay similar to standard bilzzard ladder maps".
This map is not such a map. For example, placing starting units/heros, editing unit stats, invalid locations for starting positions, setting custom forces: These are all thigns that do no belong into a melee map at all.
I assume making a normal melee map wasnt your intention in the first place. In this case, you should however upload the map with the tag "altered melee" instead of "melee", so that the map appears both for the responsible reviewers and potentially interested players, if they search for it.
As it stand, for me to review this as a melee map is pointless, as the general concepts of melee maps (evaluating creeps, itemdrops, balance,...) cannot sensibly be applied to this map.
Therefore I am setting this map to substandard. If you want this map to reviewed as an altered melee instead, please leave a message in here and I might set it back to pending. But even then I assume the maps needs major updates, starting with a proper name.
"Melee" map on the hiveworkshop generally should be understood as "map that offers unaltered gameplay similar to standard bilzzard ladder maps".
This map is not such a map. For example, placing starting units/heros, editing unit stats, invalid locations for starting positions, setting custom forces: These are all thigns that do no belong into a melee map at all.
I assume making a normal melee map wasnt your intention in the first place. In this case, you should however upload the map with the tag "altered melee" instead of "melee", so that the map appears both for the responsible reviewers and potentially interested players, if they search for it.
As it stand, for me to review this as a melee map is pointless, as the general concepts of melee maps (evaluating creeps, itemdrops, balance,...) cannot sensibly be applied to this map.
Therefore I am setting this map to substandard. If you want this map to reviewed as an altered melee instead, please leave a message in here and I might set it back to pending. But even then I assume the maps needs major updates, starting with a proper name.
