Miner.blp

[Moderator]

15:14, 15th Jun 2009
Hawkwing: It's pretty good. I think you should make the hair darker though. Red-heads' hair darkens over time to more of a brown. The colour you have used would really only be appropriate for a kid. Also, if there's any way you can brighten the center of the torso, that would be great!

Edit: It may be within your interests to take a glance at this post.

 

[AIagremm]

Strange skin. Good idea but strange.
Looks really wowish. Too wowish.
Did you use CnP? From WoW?

 

[PsychoNerdial]

Looks fine to me But maybe you should improve the Bisceps and Triceps

 

[AIagremm]

Yes, they look a little... flat.

 

[Misha]

ah... a new skin to kill :'D

well for starters:
~moustache and beard should be different and separate, it looks like a red chimp
~has no shading whatsoever, add more (especially on chest and abdomen)
~has no definition, hey, add some arm hairs and some good skin things.
~has no folds, add folds on the pants
~CnP?? if it has some remove or rework
~hair is meh, do more details and fix highlights and shadows, also tone it down.

Rating: 2.56/5 Lacking.

~Misha~

 

[Candy]

...despite of this is quite usefull, at least for me and this is my rating.

 

[Just_Spectating]

it could be like a goatee

 

[Misha]

...despite of this is quite usefull, at least for me and this is my rating.

usefulness is not enough. it needs to look good too.

 

[Coinblin]

I'll answer everyone's questions or comments here
1. No cnp from wow, or cnp from anything. I got the idea to make this guy shirtless from the wow Defias Strip Miner. I put that in the description, so it is roughly based on a wow skin I guess.
2. The beard and mustache are connected because, well, its a goatee lol
3. No shading whatsoever...? Unless everything I know about shading is a lie, this guy has plenty of it.
4. As for definition, hey, I guess I could give him a little more of a "salt of the earth" kinda feel!

 

[Tyranda101]

Yes, looks nearly same as the ones of Wow. I still think it are great details, good job! Great idea! Didn't see this sort of skins a long time!

 

[67chrome]

Lols - I don't think thats CnP, I think thats just his style - you should check the huge discussion about that on Coinblin's Mercinary skin. Though I agree with the other points - this skin needs a lot more shadding and and details on the paints would be good to - check out the defias strip miner picture attached below

 

[X.e.r.e.X]

The skin is just way too "smooth?"

 

[Craka_J]

Looks pretty cool. I don't like his hair color though. Black, white, gray, brown, or even blonde would have fitted.

 

[Sabelion]

Hehe, hes beard/mustash looks like huuuuge lips on him. xD

other than that, I think its good.

 

[Hawkwing]

~moustache and beard should be different and separate, it looks like a red chimp

Well, the original peasant is the same. It has to do with the angle of the camera. In-game it will not look quite so bad.

~has no shading whatsoever, add more (especially on chest and abdomen)

There's tons of shading. Some more on the torso would be nice, but I don't think it's a top priority.

~has no definition, hey, add some arm hairs and some good skin things.

The only place lacking definition is the torso, and that's coming back to your shading concerns.

~has no folds, add folds on the pants

Agreed, but I think this should be put off until later. There are more important things to deal with first.

~CnP?? if it has some remove or rework

Certainly not.

~hair is meh, do more details and fix highlights and shadows, also tone it down.

The shading is decent. Some highlights, maybe. And, as I said in the moderation, the colour needs to be toned down. I assume that's what you mean.

 

[Coinblin]

Thanks Hawkwing. You were very helpful.

 

[Shido]

It's 2023 and red hair is perfectly fine. I am loving those beefy abs here and arguably the closest thing I ever like about a peasant skin.

I blame Blizzy for peasant model existance.