Human Campaign Interlude

[Moderator]

14:54, 1st Jan 2009
Rui: Lacking quality (2/5). Please improve before you submit your next cinematic.
Reviewed.

 

[Septimus]

What did you actually edit over it ?

 

[Mechmap]

As much as I like seeing new cinematic makers, I unfortunatly can't say I enjoyed it more than the original. The camera angles were boring, and it didnt capture the moment of an entire city massacred with only those few corpses.

I see talent in you, so keep going with it.

 

[Ikx_1]

What did you actually edit over it ?

No i didn't. I just make new map.

 

[Rui]

√ Hive Workshop requirements (X) Camera (X) Music/Sound (X) Special effects (X) Originality (X) Terrain Screenplay

"Human Campaign Interlude" is an original cinematic map by Ikx_1, aiming to expand (I think) the interlude on Jaina's and Uther's arrivals to Stratholme after Arthas's culling. This cinematic was nothing new, I consider it worst than the original by Blizzard. There are so many things you could have done, yet you chose to simply remake it. My wish was to reject it, but since it obeys the rules...

My rating for this cinematic is 2/5 (Lacking). Reviewed. Please, improve it.

 

[Septimus]

Kinda hard blow by Rui, did't it ?