Frozen

[Moderator]

19:36, 26th Oct 2010
ap0calypse: Rejected

 

[Craka_J]

The terrain in this map is probably the best I've seen in my entire life in any game. You sir, are Christ himself when it comes to terraining.

 

[GrimReapaa]

The terrain in this map is probably the best I've seen in my entire life in any game. You sir, are Christ himself when it comes to terraining.

Haha, thanks xD! I'm not much of a terrainer but this was a special occasion for my beloved clan.

 

[light bolt30]

I don't really think the terrain is very balanced like that in terms of gold mines placement, and the distance of gold mines between other players.

 

[GrimReapaa]

You make a valid point, though I forgot the tools to edit the map with considering that I need to save it with another program because when I do it comes up with an error stating: exceeding cell limit.

 

[light bolt30]

Also fix the author name, and improve that description; maybe add screenshots, tell us about creep camps, how many items, what drops, etc, here's a list of BB Codes for you.

 

[GrimReapaa]

Haha, okay. I would most definately improve author name but like I said, unable to save - the author was supposed to be made by an unknown man considering the fact that this was an inside map, but from the recent excitement of our clan I decided to release it publicly. I'll gladly update the description tomorrow.

Also, excuse me for the description, it was hastily drawn up as I was for some reason doing this while on Wc3. xD

 

[Craka_J]

The description says the map dimensions are 468x468, meanwhile, the website says it is 224x224.

 

[light bolt30]

Why would a melee map be that big?

 

[Darkzealot_128]

Bad terrain, improperly placed item drops, bad description, thats enough for rejection.

 

[Pourquoi]

Vote for REJECTION.
Bad terrain, bad description, and author's name is different from uploader's name.

 

[Royal_Dragon12]

What the Hell is this map? I do like about the ideas but the terrain seems so... maybe too big and bad places for vision,fighting way and defense. Alsos the monsters are too imbalance and their items are imbalance,too.

 

[GrimReapaa]

The map is very basic and it seems much people disagree with it.
Also, the website says playable size: 212x212 but the warcraft 3 editor version says much different.

Also, this is a melee map for "When melee maps aren't big enough."

I am having troubles saving this map considering I need a wc3editor addon to save the exceeded limit of destructibles and hostile creeps along with the exceeded limit of cell length, otherwise I would be fixing most of your complaints.

 

[ap0calypse]

The map is very basic and it seems much people disagree with it.

Nope, everybody agrees with that statement.
The map is very basic, too basic.

Also, the website says playable size: 212x212 but the warcraft 3 editor version says much different.

Probably because it exceeds the maximum size of the regular editor.

Haha, thanks xD! I'm not much of a terrainer but this was a special occasion for my beloved clan.

You do know Craka_J was being sarcastic, right? (From your sentence, I can't derive whether you reply was meant in an ironic way or not).

Basically:
- The terrain is way too simple
- Improper starting locations (yellow amost can't move because its starting loc is too close to trees).
- You say that this map is for when a regular map is too small, but you didn't use half of the size, so that statement is complete rubbish.
- Distances are too long, warcraft IS a strategy game - if it takes your army over 5 minutes to get somewhere, it really isn't worth it.
- The second-strongest creeps (corners) are way too strong and don't even have drops... at all.
- Creep camps over level 120? How about you remove ¾^th of that?
- Some starting locations have creeps, others don't (not symmetrical).
- Drops are complete rubbish (10% for every level item from 5-10? Serathil? Seriously?)
- HEROES as creeps...

1/5, Rejected.

 

[GrimReapaa]

Yes, I have posted such a failure of a map, I myself already know this is rejected and give myself a 2/5.

I will make an entirley different melee map which will use most of the terriain, useable races, different creeps, and so forth...

 

[Craka_J]

Better luck next time!

 

[GrimReapaa]

Better luck next time!

Yeah, thanks for the support and the rep by the way. Not sure why I deserved it but hey, everyone deserves a chance I guess? xD

 

[light bolt30]

Well, if you're really going to try improve a map, might as well listen to the players feedback and see how you can fix the map or take it in as a teaching for future maps.

 

[GrimReapaa]

Ya, this really showed me flaws in my map making. Thanks!

*EDIT*

I know this is really off topic, but would anyone like to test my Role Playing Game? It's much better than this in my opinion and just needs a test to look at bugs in the beginning, which is the only part that is completed at this moment.