FateAndGlory

[Moderator]

20:05, 21st May 2009 by bounty hunter2:
Approved with a 2/5 (Lacking) rating.

You can find my full review at post #11.

 

[Cyper95]

OMG why do we have to know how you look and how you dance we really couldnt care less the name should be like this Fate And Glory instead of FateAndGlory...
now to the terrain..
i saw in wc3 world editor to check the terrain that some windmills are behind fence so they actually couldnt be entered if you think of it which makes it look abit bad,
use of blizzard cliffs.. it can be necessary in some parts but it truly does suck it hurts my eyes.. but i like that the terrain could be used strategical..
now to the gameplay not much to say a melee map so...
and also why do we have to know that your the best in your class im just not so sure you are..
Rating 3/5 rating will go up when terrain gets better that is around the only thing you need to focus on when making melee's you know

 

[Super-Sheep]

Cyper95 I guess you never played ladder? These maps are supposed to have blizzard cliffs and are not supposed to look fancy. Well, I dont see aything wrong on this terrain. Could be pretty good for a melee map, but cant judge anything if I havent tested it in-game.

 

[Revan(Rom)]

youre free to say your opinion still im not interessted in mapping anymore =)

just hf

 

[Cyper95]

i have played ladder i know blizz cliffs are supposed to be there but i just dont like them but if you could avoid them somehow it would be good you know^^

 

[Revan(Rom)]

however =)
I like blizz-cliffs and they are suposed to be in a meelemap so...
Anyway - by the way I think the terrain is ok - ofc not best but - Ive tried

 

[Cyper95]

well it is okay but i still dont like the fences infront of doors

 

[66Dragon6]

What the hell is a blizz-cliff?

 

[Cyper95]

blizzard cliff that is the one you can make with raise-one

 

[Septimus]

I have view it, but this map certainly isn't your best job. Your previous work is far better than that.

I could have sense that you are rushing the work due to the abnormal scene I seen in this map (You would laugh as well if you paid attention to the abnormal scene).

Overall - 3/5 (Useful)

If you want to know the abnormal scene, I could show it to you. By the way, I also recommend you to improve the description.

 

[bounty hunter2]

bounty hunter2's Review on FateAndGlory

FateAndGlory is an melee map for up to four players.

The terrain is good in places, such as the tiles used, and the encirnoment dodoads. However you put to much houses, and in places it looked quite rushed. You should slow it up a bit. And ease a bit with the rough dirt. The waterfalls come from nowhere?

The creeps are chosen decently, and placed aswell. However the drops are too weak. A croup consisting of five creeps drop only a tome? That must be fixed. Take a look at Blizzards drops, or Rui's or HFR's drops. They make good melees.

The neutral buildings are placed well, although fountains of mana are a no go for me. I would prefer fountains of health. Mana is more useful in many cases, and that can imbalance the game a bit.

You should package the map much better.

Approved with a 2/5 (Lacking) rating.

 

[Revan(Rom)]

haha guys, nothing against Rui ... but his meelemaps
well doesnt matter, it was my last submited map - you know im kinda got to old for wc3 17 (and yes - its to old for playing pc games and whos still playing - have just no friends - get a latina girl and dance salsa - you will understand what live is)

I hope you will not waste so many time like me years ago to spend time on mapping

Man Rui i felt in love with your meelemaps - they funny as hell

 

[knight26]

I think the whole post is just a SPAM and leaves a really bad mark on Hive...
And also i think you are annoying.( Why do you wtrite all that sh*t on posting a map?..its really unnecessary.. r u trying to be a show-off or smth?)..
(zoMG is this flaming? XD)...

On topic:
I guess i could say this is 'original'..
Also the cliffts may be too much..its an avarege meele map.

 

[Rui]

I don't know what's your problem, though I suspect it has something to do with Septimus since you apparently like his maps.
Anyway, I present good arguments to rate a map, and the same I cannot say for you. You have no morality to criticize other people's melee maps, when the majority of yours are bad, and on top of that, you don't even bother to fix them, so your opinion (rather taunting than anything else) is worth its worth.