Elemental Battlefield v.22d

[Moderator]

13:13, 16th Jun 2008
Septimus:

Good Point

[+] Very interesting concept
[+] Different element, different advantage. Had to utilize it to get advantage to overwhelm enemy
[+] Unit doesn't get stuck, which is a good thing.
[+] Good combination of element is needed if want to defeat the opponent
[+] Many different way to build up a different structure that train different unit which might give different result. Crucial if victory is needed to achieve.
[+] No bug is found.

Neutral Point

[!] The mini map preview seem ok at warcraft 3, but at hiveworkshop it seem to had problem

Bad Point

[-] Space to build structure seem to be limited, which is not a good thing.
[-] Very less element cause only had 3 element available.

Overall - 3/5
Approve
Comment : If there is more element available, I would like it even more.

 

[Septimus]

Good Point

[+] Very interesting concept
[+] Different element, different advantage. Had to utilize it to get advantage to overwhelm enemy
[+] Unit doesn't get stuck, which is a good thing.
[+] Good combination of element is needed if want to defeat the opponent
[+] Many different way to build up a different structure that train different unit which might give different result. Crucial if victory is needed to achieve.
[+] No bug is found.

Neutral Point

[!] The mini map preview seem ok at warcraft 3, but at hiveworkshop it seem to had problem

Bad Point

[-] Space to build structure seem to be limited, which is not a good thing.
[-] Very less element cause only had 3 element available.

Overall - 3/5
Approve
Comment : If there is more element available, I would like it even more.

 

[Quack_Kills.]

Currently I am working on Wind, Nature, Darkness, and Light. Expect those and a few more in the future. Despite the fact that Darkness, Light, and Nature aren't exactly elements, I believe they a big part in what makes our world unique. Thank you for the comment.

 

[Foopad]

A good map.
Nice idea, nice input. I can see there's alot of effort in this.
The game gets borring after a few tries, because you have tried most things.
Overall: Good map - Good job.
Keep up the good work.

When do you think we could see an update with more races?

 

[Quack_Kills.]

Sorry for my lack of updating this for the site. Anyways, this map is 1000x funner than the one before the update. Have fun, give feedback

(PS: I was halfway done with Wind element when I took a hiatus on the Elemental Battlefield map and am now working on a different project.)

 

[TheAncient]

I am going to be blunt and say it.

I wish rights to a map like this.

i am not saying i want the map, just if there would be a problem with using the same basic principle of multiple sides fighting in a castefight theme with elaments. nothing more. i want to create a map similar to this, and wish to know if there would be conflicts.

i dont intend to take any specific units or ideas from the map, beside arena's maybe. just wondering if i can use the same basic theme.

 

[Quack_Kills.]

Im gonna be blunt and say it:

you can have the map, if:

• You can deprotect it or find a deprotected version

• Dont do a crappy job

• And at least give cred to me

I quit wc3 recently and have moved on. So do whatever you want with the map or create similiar ones, if you just follow these simple rules.

 

[TheAncient]

1. I am not going to bother. I am doing everything from scratch.
2. I have a good team, and i have mapmaked for a long time. I dont expect it to be popular, but it wont be bad.
3. done.