Cityscape v1.5

[Moderator]

Orcnet

20:03, 14th May 2013

Comment

Review

Map Approved

Cityscape (Version 1.3) Rate Score Percent Letter 5/5 91-100 A Rate Score Percent Letter 4/5 81-90% B Rate Score Percent Letter 3/5 75-80% C Rate Score Percent Letter 2/5 70-74% D Rate Score Percent Letter 1/5 50-69% F Overview: Gameplay "Cityscpae" is a Altered Melee that shows the insides of a city like venue where players will still follow the melee rule in order to win but with new additions included in the game. "The Gameplay is still similar to the original one but I like the idea of boosting the food cap but that's just it this technique can either turn into a lag fest if this is played on a full house you could have also remove the 3 limitation of heroes and make it 4 to try out all of your race's champions." Terrain "I don't like the idea of keeping the trees as far from the main base mainly the NE has the advantage of getting lumber quickly and turning the tree into a wall is a bad idea, any else the whole map looks tight and fine though." Management "Overall it needs more decor and same goes to the widely space of each area I mean some of the expansions is small while the others can fit a full grown economy inside, try to improve your terrain materializing and same to your melee alteration plans." Total Score: Rate Score Percent Letter 9/15 80% C

 

[Binsu]

You should add some screenshots about your game. But nonethless your description is nice. I'll also review this... review later!

 

[AwzomeWulfzz]

I see nothing but an empty brown box of browness in the screenshot boxes. Fix that.

 

[Casix]

fix

I see nothing but an empty brown box of browness in the screenshot boxes. Fix that.

already fix

 

[Almia]

Nice description!

About the map.
The map is dead flat.
If this uses harvest,why are the trees too far?

 

[Legal_Ease]

Nice terrain! 5/5 this is beautiful.

 

[Casix]

Added new race (trolls)

 

[maniawar3]

i test your map and find several problems

first: the trolls cant build priest tent and troll beast tent without a bastion so human race is necessary to build that .

second : the legendary and unic claws that have of effect put poison per time does not work with them I neither poison or attack air units.

third : the fel orcs build orcs buildings so why buy fel orc builder?.

fourth : the global improvements like for example backpack does not work i have to research the same thing in each race.

fifth : using troll i need to have eternity tree and black citadel to buy poison orb and Parchment of treatment.

pd: i play with orc race.
pd2: srry my english is not good.

 

[Casix]

i test your map and find several problems

first: the trolls cant build priest tent and troll beast tent without a bastion so human race is necessary to build that .

second : the legendary and unic claws that have of effect put poison per time does not work with them I neither poison or attack air units.

third : the fel orcs build orcs buildings so why buy fel orc builder?.

fourth : the global improvements like for example backpack does not work i have to research the same thing in each race.

fifth : using troll i need to have eternity tree and black citadel to buy poison orb and Parchment of treatment.

pd: i play with orc race.
pd2: srry my english is not good.

Thanks guy i fix this now.

 

[cleavinghammer]

The Centaur and Skeleton heroes can be bought infinitely.