Charging Undead TD

[Moderator]

Orcnet

18:06, 3rd June 2013

Comment

Review

Map Approved

Charging Undead! (No Version/s Stated) Rate Score Percent Letter 5/5 91-100 A Rate Score Percent Letter 4/5 81-90% B Rate Score Percent Letter 3/5 75-80% C Rate Score Percent Letter 2/5 70-74% D Rate Score Percent Letter 1/5 50-69% F Overview: Gameplay "Charging Undead!" is a single-player on a tower defense map. "Towers take too long to build, I suggest ditching it so that any possible and on-building process towers are ready on an incoming wave, the level wave gauge is bugged, I successfully defeated level 2 then the leaderboard for the level 3 and level 4 started popping out, mind fixing it." Terrain "Terrain seems fine right now, but try detailing those city buildings in a good way instead of making them look like walls since this is a single player TD map, it won't lag the player much." Management "After testings, fix those bad bugs and adjust the tower's characteristics, any else can be approved." Total Score: Rate Score Percent Letter 9/15 80% C

 

[David]

Heres my review:

Good:

It was so fun to play and it is balanced.
It is functional pretty well
Terrain was nice for such a map
Paths were well made and very precise

My vote: 3/5 Vote for aproval.

My message: I really enjoyed it.

 

[HammerFist132]

Thank you man, really nice to hear that.
That was the main point of the map:
Easy to understand, fun to play and to be classic.
Nice to hear that people enjoy this kind of maps

Also I have plans for future update, for excample Death Knigh will have 4-5 special spells, other things will be suprise

 

[David]

Thank you man, really nice to hear that.
That was the main point of the map:
Easy to understand, fun to play and to be classic.
Nice to hear that people enjoy this kind of maps

Also I have plans for future update, for excample Death Knigh will have 4-5 special spells, other things will be suprise

Awesome, I am glad to give people suggestions and reviews

 

[HammerFist132]

Btw, expect Boss Fight (with no import too), in one weel

 

[Doomguy80]

You should define the type and category of your map.

 

[Lichkings slave]

I think that I am gonna enjoy this map

 

[HammerFist132]

I think that I am gonna enjoy this map

I hope you will ;p.

Btw after my brother have played this maps, with only 3 types of towers and will ultry stupid strategy I have decided that map should be at least little advanced. For start guard and poison towers are nerfed a bit.
Also I have found few bugs so I will update map tomorrow.

 

[Binsu]

Hell_Master in! Hi there, played your map and have lots of fun. Everything in it looks really good. Let me put up a review here:

[+] Good Points:
-Terrain here looks really good for a TD map. Enough spaces for towers to be builded was made and terrain looks very neat.
-Few towers but quite useful in each battle.
-I like the ideas of the Bases and that other tower that gives Auras such as increase attack speed and slow.
-Towers are quite good and has the balanced range attack.

[-] Bad Points:
-None

[] Suggestions:
-Terrain looks good at its state but maybe you can add more decors but make sure it doesnt cause inconvience in building towers.
-I would like to see more towers and Aura giving towers in following next updates.

Overall, this is quite a good TD map with good terrain, balanced towers and enemies. Rated 4/5 and +4 REP to you.

Voting also for Approval!

Hell_Master out!

 

[UgoUgo]

Well mate, Im in a good mood to review a map, so I did.

The map is fine, but perhaps you can add more 'flavour' to it, some suggestions would be:

• Sound effects when each level is starting?
• Now all Im doing in the TD is waiting and building, maybe you should add something that can make us work with our fingers, such as a building that has all sorts of aoe spell that needs mana to cast (Thunder Clap, any profitable aoe spell etc etc)
• Now I know this is a TD, but then theres a way to improve the terrain. My suggestion would be add an environment outside of theTD area, this can at least please the players' eyes.
• Dont hate me, but I think the description is not informative enough. Here's a series of pictures regarding it:

Hidden

The actual sentence should be 'Has no attack, but slows down nearby enemy units.' Also it would be nice if you tell us how much % it slows, so that we know the tower is worth of our money.

Once again, it would be nice to tell us how many % chance of critical strike with X times of damage.

How many damage per X seconds, exactly?

How much % of movement speed does it slows? You can check this at gameplay constant.

Im assuming this is a bug. You must have forgotten to remove it somehow, because this tower is much weaker, and it is found on Advanced Blazing Tower.

So it reduces speed, but the name of ability is 'Speed Up'. And, as usual, it would be nice to see how much % of speed it decreases.

Same problem.

• Also, since this is a TD map, therefore spending money wisely is important. I think the description regarding the towers could provide more details, such as:

Hidden

Arrow Tower
Basic tower, capable of killing creeps in a hit at early stage. Moderate damage, High attack rate, single target.

Attack: 10 - 20 (Chaos)
Attack Speed: 1.0 s
Ability: Critical Strike (20%, 3x damage)

Attacks land and air units.

That's all for now! Good luck.

 

[HammerFist132]

Hey people thanks for review. Thanks to the hellmaster and ugougo I will start working on all thing you told me.
So If I can finish all things today I will update map.
Thank you once more
(ugougo I hated you once , now I like all things you say)

 

[Binsu]

No problem just doing my job on helping Orcie review maps and also make your map got approved. Mostly I find Ugo's suggestion so neat and useful. =)

 

[David]

Hell_Master in! Hi there, played your map and have lots of fun. Everything in it looks really good. Let me put up a review here:

[+] Good Points:
-Terrain here looks really good for a TD map. Enough spaces for towers to be builded was made and terrain looks very neat.
-Few towers but quite useful in each battle.
-I like the ideas of the Bases and that other tower that gives Auras such as increase attack speed and slow.
-Towers are quite good and has the balanced range attack.

[-] Bad Points:
-None

[] Suggestions:
-Terrain looks good at its state but maybe you can add more decors but make sure it doesnt cause inconvience in building towers.
-I would like to see more towers and Aura giving towers in following next updates.

Overall, this is quite a good TD map with good terrain, balanced towers and enemies. Rated 4/5 and +4 REP to you.

Voting also for Approval!

Hell_Master out!

Good review.

 

[Binsu]

Thanks, bro! =D

 

[Orcnet]

approved but there are some problems found in the map, see details on top

 

[HammerFist132]

Thanks orcnet, fast review . Btw I have finished v1.1. Will update it soonest possible. Most of changes are done by suggestions by ugougo.
Just to finish last boss and will add it.

 

[HammerFist132]

Update (sorry for double post, if mods want to blend them, do it):

This fast update comes with much detailed tower description (suggested by ugougo),
working on additional balancing (nerfing guard towers, balancing invading levels), fixed plenty bugs (some of them reported by ugougo, plenty others founded by me), some terrain changes.

I will update description in first post, but I cannot currently (you can guess I am on mobile). Ugougo added to credits.

 

[ILH]

nice and simple ^^
+REp

 

[HammerFist132]

thanks man, new update in week, you can expect new tower(bank for bonus gold), towers with casting spells, etc.

 

[Freeze87]

Testing....

 

[ironymon]

Wish it was longer. But just for that to take away a point is cruel, 5/5.

 

[HammerFist132]

Wish it was longer. But just for that to take away a point is cruel, 5/5.

thx, I dont have wc any more and cannot extend it ,also I dont belive it is ope source. if it is you can extend it and upload your own xD

 

[Whiteagle]

The map was nice, a little short but the strategies was not too simple nor complexe