BTNWinterberry

[Darkfang]

looks more like winter onion, I like the bi pic, but the small will look bad ingame

 

[Scias]

The icicles dropping from the fruit don't seem to have much difference in depth between each other, I prefer the ones on the leaves. It's also a bit odd that the icicles only come from behind the fruit.
Also the right side icicle really bothers me on the small icon size, it is really thick, choppy and stands out a lot.

Looks pretty good anyhow, I like the design and the style.

 

[Maxwell]

The icicles dropping from the fruit don't seem to have much difference in depth between each other

To be honest It is supposed to be like interesting background, nothing special. But I guess it really can be easily misunderstood as bad drawn icicles.

 

[Darkfang]

To be honest It is supposed to be like interesting background, nothing special. But I guess it really can be easily misunderstood as bad drawn icicles.

the problem is in the saturation of some colors, bg should be more dull, the bright spots on the "onion" should be dull too, the leaves should be also more light/clear with less shadows and more dull so that they look good on the icon