Btnstop

[Moderator]

05:09, 23rd Dec 2011
Pyramidhe@d: Why is there blinding light on one corner and why is the middle bar bent? As a sort of a sign or a symbol, this is very confusing.

 

[EloTheMan]

Its pretty well made, but I got a feeling that the light is to bright.

If it is going to be used as intended you will have to make more. (I read the desc, just pointing it out.)

 

[Sin'dorei300]

Its pretty well made, but I got a feeling that the light is to bright.

If it is going to be used as intended you will have to make more. (I read the desc, just pointing it out.)

Agree..

 

[cyniccynic]

It's meant as a shiny golden stop sign.

 

[xIceShotx]

It's meant as a shiny golden stop sign.

I like the shiny but it is too much shiny ^^

 

[Apheraz Lucent]

This icon oddly reminds me of this style: http://www.hiveworkshop.com/forums/icons-541/btnstop-160384/?prev=search=cancel&d=list&r=20, which means that it lacks shadows and highlights, as well as definitions. Your icon is way too bright, and even after you applied correct bordering to get the Warcraft Feeling, it stands out too much. The background should be black, not gray, since it just kills the icon even more, and it's very plain in the icon's center. I would like to see a more texture on the icon itself, since it's just a yellow circle with some weird shadows all over it. If you want shine, better use soft brushes with low opacity, rather than spam of white color all over the place.

Also, use continuos moves of White and Dark Yellow colors (never black, always darker colors) in a circular motion, in order to get some light source and shadows which are nonexistent on this icon.

Current rating: 2/5 - Lacking

Reference images you could use

Shadow and Light

Bright and lovely appearance

Golden Texture

Edit: Oh, and you should change the name to something else, since this will replace the original Stop icon, which someone might need, if it's imported correctly.