BTNPotionred

[Moderator]

19:59, 2nd Nov 2009
Pyramidhe@d: the glass effect is jaw dropping and you got the transparency pretty much perfect

 

[kola]

...

dude.. the potion is purple not red <===

 

[Mr.Goblin]

hah, I know, it just a name, it was supposed to be red, but I changed the color afterwords.

 

[kola]

lol ok

also.. except the name/color its rly good..

 

[Panda]

Nice work Goblin!

 

[Soul Theft]

nice

 

[Deolrin]

Uh... You serious? This is so much better than your mushrooms!

This is probably my favorite icon of yours from now on... Keep up the great work, man!

 

[Palaslayer]

it is good, but still not your best.

 

[TheHunterKiller]

The glass is wonderful. Looks blizzardish too. Nice work.

 

[FrIkY]

The glass looks flat and kinda 2D-ish, but the liquid inside is in move and has a 3D-ish appearance. I don't know, maybe you should change the shape of the glass...

 

[Pyramidhe@d]

btw, change your icon name. i forgot to tell you

 

[Fire and Ice]

The glass looks flat and kinda 2D-ish, but the liquid inside is in move and has a 3D-ish appearance. I don't know, maybe you should change the shape of the glass...

I second that. Just a suggestion, but you could try making the liquid less translucent, will look less like colored water and more of a potion... and round out the base of the glass and at the rim, reduce the sharpness of the lines inside the glass by a bit, may help.
Oh and er... forgot to mention that because the lines inside the glass are too clearly defined it ends up looking like a glass inside a glass, which makes the liquid look like just another layer slapped over the whole thing and ends up having it feel like the liquid is displaced outside the glass... okay maybe not THAT bad but you know what i mean.
And uhh,

dude.. the potion is purple not red <===

 

[Greedforce]

Well it´´s not red it´s purple or maybe pink but one thing´s for sure; it´s a great icon.