BTNPortal

[Moderator]

22:25, 20th Jul 2009
Hawkwing: Only now did I realize what this was. Now that I know though, I'll admit the quality is decent. It lacks depth however, which is what you should work on next.

 

[mjllonir]

I didn't make many WIPS, so I'm giving you my base and what I got in the end before I added the icon borders. Mabe I'll try to get more next time.

 

[Panda]

Review,
------------------------------------
1-Thanks for some pictures at least, anyway.
2-Overall nice idea, but poor use of the brush tool in the middle, make another design or effect in middle or outside of middle.
3-Color scheme is lacking i think, maybe add some more vibrant colors? Like maybe since your doing blue, added "Cool" colors as shown, Blue, Green, Purple ex.. use these and create some sort of design. or "color scheme"
4-ATC is wrong, when making "ATC" you need to put on passive border and then put on the ATC border then your done.
------------------------------------
(All my recommendations to your icon, you can choose to use these or not,

your choice.)
Thanks, Army-of-pandas.
----------------------------------------

 

[mjllonir]

Ah ok. I'll make some changes right now, I'll come up with something a bit more cool . And thank you for the ATC notice.

 

[Panda]

No problem.

 

[mjllonir]

Here are some new WIPS that I made to show the changes.

And I updated the actual thread, so tell me if you like the new ones, and what I should change!

Thank you very much!

 

[Panda]

No problem again, anyway, hmm.. the first one has the best detail i would say. Too add to it maybe fix up the middle part again, remove the big white part and then add other details and effects,
Here, i did this to show you what i mean.

 

[mjllonir]

*Updated completely*

 

[Panda]

Looks nice, good improvements.

 

[mjllonir]

Latest WIP

Here is my Latest WIP, basically the final product of the whole thing.

 

[a7xpwns3]

+ Creative
+ Cool color scheme

? Takes awhile to see what it really is

- Needs more color usage along with more blending
- Doesn't fit WC3 style

Hey, don't give up on this one! It has a good idea in it, but it lacks execution. It needs to look more WC3ish. You can do this by adding more color blending, along with more shading and colors.

 

[krisserz]

Nice idea for portal, but you should move up the endings. Now it looks more like sandglass.

 

[breebree123]

looks like a book rather than a portal. .3/5

 

[mjllonir]

I updated with the help of Army-of-Pandas. Big thanks to you for all your help.

 

[Panda]

When you edit this mjillonir find my layer that has the yellow backround on it and make it a fitting color, i didn't know what color you wanted.

 

[mjllonir]

Meh, yellow was pretty cool in my opinion

 

[Panda]

Ok, just checking.