BTNHolyShield

[Moderator]

20:48, 12th Apr 2009
Paladon:

Creativity: 2/5
Quality: 3/10
Status: Rejected until updated
Comment: Appears still very 2-dimensional. You could add more details next to shadings and highlights. The shield should get a more metallic appearance.

 

[a7xpwns3]

MSPaint is BAD for you.
Try out Paint.net, GIMP, Paintshop, or anything else you might want OTHER THAN MSP

 

[Zombie]

Lacks geometry, shading and proper definiton. You'll have to further detail the object and add shading.

 

[medion505]

Have now updated, has a bit more definition but I cannot put too much in as it is supposed to be like a shield made out of light.

For the record I use Photoshop 7, and will hopefully get cs3 or cs4 soon.

I have put the two side by side to show the difference, the one on the left is the old one the one on the right the new.

 

[a7xpwns3]

Looking better, but I still dont think enough to be approved.

 

[darkdeathknight]

Shouldn't it be symmetrical?

 

[Paladon]

It is still not really shaded or detailed.

 

[medion505]

Updated, cannot tell if it is more detailed or any better

 

[Paladon]

The shield should get a more metallic appearance.
It's still very 2-dimensional.
However, try to improve the PAS, DISBTN, DISATC and DISPAS borders as well.
The black border should always blur with the icon, while the ATC version is an exception.