BTNBurningArcher

[Moderator]

14:29, 4th Feb 2014
Kimbo: I'm tossed up between the usefulness of this icon, as stated in the comments one very similar which is mostly handrawn already exists. I will decide in afew days after talking with afew people.

Sin'dorei300: Approved cuz of usefulness.

 

[SpasMaster]

No offence, mate but I3lackDeath already uploaded a way better icon with the same theme and idea in mind:

 

[Remixer]

I actually prefer Nealdros'.

 

[Nealdros]

No offence at all, it just spawned up randomly, i did almost nothing XD it's here just if someone (like Remixer for example) thinks it's worth.

 

[PlankingWolf]

No offence, mate but I3lackDeath already uploaded a way better icon with the same theme and idea in mind:

Well, this icon is very Warcraftish compared to BlackDeath's icon.
I'd approve this out of usefulness, but would have a low rating and be sent to Blizzard Entertainment.
Edit: Plus, BlackDeath wanted to know HOW Blizzard did their icons, while Nealdros wanted a fitting icon for the burning archer.
Some minor things to point out too:
The burning archer doesn't have metal shoulder plates
The burning archer also doesn't have spikes on it's non-existent metal shoulder plates
If you know how to edit those, I think this deserves an approval.

 

[Nealdros]

I agree, if you look in the info i wrote Blizzard Entertainment i kinda like I3lackDeath's one more too XD I think i will upload a couple more useful-ish recolors but i'll check similarity first

 

[Nealdros]

Some minor things to point out too:
The burning archer doesn't have metal shoulder plates
The burning archer also doesn't have spikes on it's non-existent metal shoulder plates
If you know how to edit those, I think this deserves an approval.

I will try removing the spike and the shoulderplate, the spike i'm sure i will make it in about 1/2 hrs but the shoulderplate will be tough, 'cause the model should have a bone shoulder i'm not sure i can draw (i'm an engineer not a designer, i'm really bad at this). Give me a couple of days and i'll get it done somehow.

 

[UgoUgo]

I'll be honest.

I might be the only one, but as an icon maker I'm really offended by the appearance of all these recolored icon.

 

[Nealdros]

I am sorry, i'm not adding any more recolors anyhow. Maybe i'll create a tutorial and explain how to make and how to choose them.

 

[Nealdros]

Well, this icon is very Warcraftish compared to BlackDeath's icon.
I'd approve this out of usefulness, but would have a low rating and be sent to Blizzard Entertainment.
Edit: Plus, BlackDeath wanted to know HOW Blizzard did their icons, while Nealdros wanted a fitting icon for the burning archer.
Some minor things to point out too:
The burning archer doesn't have metal shoulder plates
The burning archer also doesn't have spikes on it's non-existent metal shoulder plates
If you know how to edit those, I think this deserves an approval.

Does this look better?
If it does, shall I replace the others?

 

[Binsu]

Even for a recolored icon this is somehow useful but I agree with UgoUgo that recolor icons are somehow being spammed or being overdone.

This can be approved (but not an icon moderator) but if you want to have better results in this. Try giving something more in it instead of recoloring it. Look at I3lackDeath's icon as a basis but do not completely copy it and you'll see that he made some considerable changes and thus making it better.

But you had a nice start and maybe in the future you can make some icons completely drawn by you. Good luck!

 

[Orcnet]

So I guess this fits Clinkz Eastwood eh? idk seems cool.

 

[GaLaxY_256]

Clinkz has it's own icon. BTNSkeletonMage . Oh and sorry for necro

 

[Chen]

Clinkz has it's own icon. BTNSkeletonMage . Oh and sorry for necro

He stole the icon for Pugna lol

 

[Map Designer]

No offence, mate but I3lackDeath already uploaded a way better icon with the same theme and idea in mind:

Link pls

BTNFireArmor