BTNBluePlanet

[Moderator]

09:28, 10th Aug 2009
zombie2279: Very simple at the moment and it looks rather flat aswell. Try adding some more decorative elements, an asteroid ring, some craters, darker spots, mountains and different color schemes.

08:55, 12th Aug 2009
zombie2279: Rejected until updated.

09:05, 26th Aug 2009
zombie2279: Changes made, useful.

 

[Licheus]

It looks good. I think it could be improved, though. Hard to say how, but maybe a bit more shading is needed. Btw, what is it ment to represent?

 

[Latecat]

Because it had no name when i posted this msg - i would say that
It fits for a coin.
4/5.

 

[RED BARON]

It looks good. I think it could be improved, though. Hard to say how, but maybe a bit more shading is needed. Btw, what is it ment to represent?

A sky covered planet... An icy planet.. No idea.

I imagined that some could thing of it as a planet seconds before a big beam of light hits it (You gotta think creative for that one).

Others might just think of it as a random planet in space..

Happy you both like it though - Makes it more likely that I'll upload my others some day.

 

[Latecat]

Either its juts me or the planet is flat
Other than that - very nice icon.
5/5.

 

[Licheus]

Yup, I agree with mare, and I look forward to see those other icons some day. =)

 

[Panda]

Looks good but the shape is a bit lacking, or how the shading doesn't really make it looks rounded. Re-do the shading too make it looks 3-Dish and add more detail and maybe some stars in the backround and you will have yourself a great planet.

 

[OnkelManfred]

you should fix those borders - especially the DIS ones look horrible :/

offtopic: 200th post

 

[RED BARON]

Looks good but the shape is a bit lacking, or how the shading doesn't really make it looks rounded. Re-do the shading too make it looks 3-Dish and add more detail and maybe some stars in the backround and you will have yourself a great planet.

Actually it has all that - And the 3D appears nice. But it is only on the large one... You can't see them on the small version

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Try looking at it for some time and it will get more and more 3D

----------------------------------------------------------------------

WOW! I spent my 2000th post here?! Damn

 

[Panda]

Ok Red, and i forgot too add that the ATC border is wrong and so is the PAS.

 

[RED BARON]

Ok Red, and i forgot too add that the ATC border is wrong and so is the PAS.

Okay... I would advice that you gave that comment in another manner.

At any rate, thanks for noticing the PAS - Updated (can't see it on the pictures though). ATC is fine.. no black border behind it is needed.

 

[Panda]

Hmm, ok then. anyway this looks good/creative nice job.

 

[breebree123]

needs more shading on the planet, + its kinda blurry
well
3/5

 

[TheHunterKiller]

It looks moar like a coin and i can't see those islands very well. But it's still nice.

 

[RED BARON]

Thanka AMP

needs more shading on the planet, + its kinda blurry
well
3/5

Both due to the size - But I might consider making the shade larger... (as said fine on the larger version)

It looks more like a coin and i can't see those islands very well. But it's still nice.

Thanks, and yea I also wish they could be more clearly defined in the small version

 

[MGCǂSpectre]

Very useful! Although I don't have a Neptune planet atm. Imo so many versions like PASBTN and upgardes are needless.

 

[TheHunterKiller]

Pretty cool now.

 

[RED BARON]

Very useful! Although I don't have a Neptune planet atm. Imo so many versions like PASBTN and upgardes are needless.

Some might need it.. Dunno. Now they have a choice. Happy you like it

 

[The_Grapist]

Pretty nice icon.
I see you put effort in it and its approved.
So i am only here to comment on the approved.

COMMENT:Its useful for space or any other map that needs earth icon.

 

[Panda]

Looks very nice now, good job.

 

[RED BARON]

Looks very nice now, good job.

Thanks.. Putting effort into making what I already made on the small visible on the smaller paid off

 

[Spet]

Nice icon, but maybe give it more value and shading so it does not look flat, but overall 4/5

 

[RED BARON]

Nice icon, but maybe give it more value and shading so it does not look flat, but overall 4/5

It has lots of shading... and appears round, but thanks for the rating anyway

 

[Dj0z]

NEED!... Moar planets!! 5/5 +rep

 

[RED BARON]

NEED!... Moar planets!! 5/5 +rep

Well thanks

 

[Dj0z]

I'm using it in my map (credit given ofc) for Jupiter.
Any way you could do Mars, Venus, Saturn and this kind of things too?

 

[RED BARON]

I'm using it in my map (credit given ofc) for Jupiter.
Any way you could do Mars, Venus, Saturn and this king of things too?

I could make those yes, but I dunno if I can make the king of things as I really don't know what that is.

It will however not be done in just a few days.

Happy that you can use it

 

[Dj0z]

That is gonna be great ^^ I do not care much about the delay, the map i'm using it for is 3 years old already lol... Just let me know when you're done . Also i already have the Sun and another planet to make up for it for now.

*Fixed kind of things lol.