BTNapple

[Moderator]

16:59, 7th Aug 2011
Pyramidhe@d: Too simple, too cartoony.

 

[Jazztastic]

I feel that this icon is too cartoony. The light spot looks too big. The apple needs some color variations and needs to be shaded to make it 3D

 

[BeTaGod-]

I feel that this icon is too cartoony. The light spot looks too big. The apple needs some color variations and needs to be shaded to make it 3D

Plus i deeply dislike the background -.-

 

[darkdeathknight]

Yeah, the BG must be black

 

[Legion_King]

Looks too simple, shadings needed aye.

 

[The Panda]

You already know stuff about the background, now lets work on the shine on the apple, i wouldn't use that kind of shape for the shine. I would do like a curved think line coming down from the top of the apple towards the bottom, but not stretching the whole apple, just around the middle of it. Also, you do need to add shading to give the 3-d effect to the apple. I would do these things.