BTNANAHolyHealFixed

[Moderator]

17:39, 19th Feb 2009
Paladon:
EDIT: Rejected until updated. It's too much lacking in definition aspects.

 

[CloudMax]

Highly Recommended

LTGH: Nice! =D Maybe some colours would be good but it looks awesome! Maybe some yellow and a little little blue.

 

[Paladon]

What is this? Somekind of black-white screenshot? I have no idea.

 

[Need_O2]

It looks like a screen shot from somewhere lol
And instead of Holy Heal Id call this Sorrow Sphere

 

[CloudMax]

He told me that he is going to add yellow to it when he comes home.
I think it will look much better in yellow :]
Thats why i gave 5/5 cus i can only rate one time.

 

[Anachron]

I am gonna change it yellow and some more holy.
Actually this is no screenshot from anywhere.
In the middle its meant to be some holy wings, but I guess its to white.

 

[adythewolf]

DISSAPROVED

I can't say it's not a good icon. But it's black-and-white, and I cant understand too much just by looking at it.

Indeed, you need to recolour it, or if you like the black-and-white theme, just make it look like something.

 

[CloudMax]

He said above that he is going to add colours :O

 

[Need_O2]

"Paladon: Very unclear, black-white only. YOu're hopefully going to update this as you announced."

WTF ???
Grayscale is an >>ART<< you cant say "meh black-white only"

This icon is very good its just not Holy Heal

 

[CloudMax]

The point is that you cant really see what its suppost to be when its black/white and its such a mess. But it will be more clean and look better with colour. I think thats the reason to why he said so.

 

[Paladon]

"Paladon: Very unclear, black-white only. YOu're hopefully going to update this as you announced."

WTF ???
Grayscale is an >>ART<< you cant say "meh black-white only"

This icon is very good its just not Holy Heal

Too bad that this is a warcraft 3 resource website and not an art forum.
I know that greyscale is an "art", but such an icon is simply unesable under normal conditions ingame, believe me, i tested.
Additionally, the greyscale technique mostly spoils detailed 64x64 icons. In this case, it's simply unclear.

I have still no idea what a single part of this icon may represent.
If you got a problem with this, you are free to discuss it with me via pm/chat/msn.

 

[Anachron]

I've updated this icon, here you can see the result:

 

[CloudMax]

If the middle is suppost to be wings, cant you try to use the colours you have now but make the wings white, that way it would be easier to see what it is.

 

[Anachron]

If the middle is suppost to be wings, cant you try to use the colours you have now but make the wings white, that way it would be easier to see what it is.

Its supposed to be 2 wings together thats why I call it holy heal...

 

[CloudMax]

Well, its hard to see the wings, thats what im trying to say :|

 

[Anachron]

Well, its hard to see the wings, thats what im trying to say :|

Hm damn Anyway I hope its enough to get approved.

 

[CloudMax]

Maybe the colour is enough to get it aproved since people is like "ohh, that looks shiny, it gotta be healing"
Even if you dont see what its suppost to be, it looks cool.

 

[Need_O2]

Now its called "Soul Storm"

 

[Paladon]

I have still no idea. Could you give me a larger version or did you draw this on 64x64?

 

[FrIkY]

What the...? Looks like some... collapse, impact, explosion, thingy...

 

[CloudMax]

Yupp, its really hard to see what its suppost to be :/

 

[Deon]

I see some top-down view on a forest with white mass.