Broad sword of the forgotten Warloard

[Moderator]

13:16, 19th Nov 2009
DonDustin: the texture is too stretched at the moment.

 

[Dark Soul]

Hmm.. Doesnt really look like a sword. Maybe give it a pointed edge?

 

[Thfatman]

Yea, I think it would look a lot better with a pointed edge. Until then 2.5/5

 

[Forgotten_Warlord]

Lol, its not suppose to have a pointed edge... Its the type of sword it is. And this is a common type of sword.

Example

 

[Misha]

Lol, its not suppose to have a pointed edge... Its the type of sword it is. And this is a common type of sword.

Example

one thing buddy, i don't care if that's a common or rare sword, the texture choice and the wrap are horrendous. so you better fix that one up ASAP

i'm surprised this didn't get rejected earlier for such a bad wrap

 

[NFWar]

Shape is like at BASEBALL bat :S Dont you have any imagination to make better?
Experiment with this.

 

[Anachron]

Who is able to held swords that are bigger as the person itself?

 

[Dark Soul]

Who is able to held swords that are bigger as the person itself?

Cloud? xD Anyway, the sharp edged thing doesnt only apply to the tip of the sword, it applies to the sides too. This sword is... rounded! Looks more like a club than a sword. Work on it!

 

[Illidan_Hunter]

It looks like a meat sword for me.

 

[AbstractCreativity]

That is one, err, broad (...) sword.
Right, anyway... I agree with Misha. The wrap could undoubtly use some improvement. And I really suggest making the razor thinner. It's way too broad. In my opinion, anyway.

 

[Forgotten_Warlord]

Bad Wrap? how so? I made the texture myself... And its not rounded... it does have sharp edges look at the mesh before you say that. Reject it if you don't want it up.

 

[Misha]

Bad Wrap? how so? I made the texture myself... And its not rounded... it does have sharp edges look at the mesh before you say that. Reject it if you don't want it up.

checked:
My apologies then, the wrap is good, the sword is thin enough. only thing is that it's too big. it may be made like that but... you should make it smaller in overall, because the hand guard is too wide. Hmm.. i'm not sure.. but the particles could have a bit.. less in number...

oh well wrap is still a bit stretched, but it's cool.

what you need is a better screenshot of the sword.

 

[HailFireer]

Mesh is very very bad. Give it something. Doesn't have to be a brick wall.

New texture and wrap for blade.

Handle is OK at mesh, I think wrap looks OK too.


OK = lacking in mod grading.

 

[Thfatman]

Lol, its not suppose to have a pointed edge... Its the type of sword it is. And this is a common type of sword.

Example

All but one of those swords have a pointed edge...

Anyway, I still think that if you're going make a flat edged sword, you need to have some so of point

 

[Alfagar]

nice, Lol it doesnt need a pointy edge, but it still would be greater when it would have a more warlordy form

 

[Misha]

Mesh is very very ugly. Give it something. Doesn't have to be a brick wall.

New texture and wrap for blade.

Handle is OK at mesh, I think wrap looks OK too.


OK = lacking in mod grading.

Hailfireer, rework that post or you'll be reported. K?

model is not ugly, it was my fault =_=

 

[HailFireer]

Bad, or what ever.

It has no good looking shape to make me use it in my map...

 

[Thfatman]

Well, that's just your map. I mean, it's not like just because it's bad in your map that no one should use it.

 

[HailFireer]

Dude it will look same in all maps...

Your comment has no sense what so ever. Its a sane game = looks same everywhere...

 

[chilla_killa]

The texture you made is very good, but the wrapping is aweful, it's much to stretched.
Also the wrap on the handle could be improved much better.
But all in all it's cool 3,5/5

 

[Thfatman]

Dude it will look same in all maps...

Your comment has no sense what so ever. Its a sane game = looks same everywhere...

My comment made no sense? Umm, sane game? What I was trying to say though, which you must not have understood, is just because you don't like, doesn't mean that no one will like it. Like, I personally think this would look a lot better with a pointed tip, but that's just me. So just because you don't like it doesn't mean you should say this can never be used in maps.

 

[Forgotten_Warlord]

I'm in the process of redesigning it...

 

[HailFireer]

Well, blade. Handle looks good and should stay that way.

Blade is what takes it down.
And wrap.

Just so you know, sometimes when I get what I want with a wrap, its not good. Mods would kill ya for it, even if you personally like it.

 

[Forgotten_Warlord]

Well, blade. Handle looks good and should stay that way.

Blade is what takes it down.
And wrap.

Just so you know, sometimes when I get what I want with a wrap, its not good. Mods would kill ya for it, even if you personally like it.

lol yeah I'm aware of this

 

[Dark Soul]

Ahh, looks much better now!

 

[Thfatman]

I have not used it in game yet, but from the picture it is a very nice improvement.

 

[Misha]

I'm in the process of redesigning it...

I don't like the new pointed one... You should revert the blade for flat tip and then just slightly rotate all 3 vertexes of the blade tip so that they now stand as / or \ however you prefer.

And for the god's sake HailFireer. Stop trolling! The blade is fine, the wrap is good. Stop posting useless and aggravating comments or i'll report you right now.

 

[Leeroy]

Really ugly wrap. Just use a metal texture from the Human's gluescreen.

 

[Forgotten_Warlord]

Really ugly wrap. Just use a metal texture from the Human's gluescreen.

no. then it won't be original

 

[Reichling]

Hmm it looks kinda well bad the wrap looks crappy and the shape is way off