Brill

[Moderator]

Vengeancekael: Private Message
Date: 2011/Nov/27 12:17:07

Reasons:

Other:
Check out the tutorials section: Tutorials
Check out the Map Development Section: Map Development Section
Check out the World Editor Help Zone (Trigger issues, object editor, overall WE issues): WE Help Zone
Comment: *Bonus Goldmines
*Enough Wood
*Symmetric, just the bottom right part needs some tweaking
*Neat looking terrain
*Different item drops
*Both Goblin and mercenary shops
*Green creeps close to starting points
*Add another tavern at the top of the center red creeps
*Replace the center goldmine by a Fountain health or a dragon mercenary building


Fix the red things mentioned and it'll get a 5/5 rating.

Approved with a 4/5 rating.
Admin Contact - Resource Moderation - Rules

 

[Vengeancekael]

*Bonus Goldmines
*Enough Wood
*Symmetric, just the bottom right part needs some tweaking
*Neat looking terrain
*Different item drops
*Both Goblin and mercenary shops
*Green creeps close to starting points
*Add another tavern at the top of the center red creeps
*Replace the center goldmine by a Fountain health or a dragon mercenary building


Fix the red things mentioned and it'll get a 5/5 rating.

Approved with a 4/5 rating.

 

[Ken-E]

Full Review

Looks awfully dull though, basing my first impression on minimap. Anyway, gonna try this one, might leave review for the next 3 or more days. Also add some screenshots, that would give more idea of your map.

EDIT: A satisfying, fun, and fast melee map. A great one, really. The village feels like its actually a village, the design on making that didn't detach itself from terraining and making it a melee map, and I like that. It's symmetrical and that always matters alot for a melee map. The doodads are also cleverly emplaced everywhere making it feel fresh and new for a village map. The only thing I didn't like the gold mine in the middle, I suggest you change it to a shop, though I think its only me and I can't point out why I didn't like it, so it isn't a major flaw.
Overall, I'll give it 3.5/5

 

[lonepair]

The map looks pretty nice and totally symmetrical to me. The placing of gold mines is creative. I'm giving a 5/5

 

[RunningFrag]

Updated the map and added screenshots. Thank you for your comments.